And Jehovah was angry with Solomon, because his heart was turned away from Jehovah the God of Israel, who had appeared to him twice,
The king who built the temple has ended up worshipping the gods of his foreign wives. Two questions follow: how does a man who saw God twice end here, and what does God's anger mean for someone He has blessed?
The chapter repeats one phrase: his wives turned away his heart. One writer shows what that describes, and how long it took.
H. L. Rossier"His wives turned away his heart" — the word is repeated in verse 4. It is a terrible thing when what belongs to the world lodges in the heart and takes control of it. It turns the affections away from their only object toward vile, shameful, guilty objects... It took time for this sowing to the flesh to bear its fruit. Who would have believed that the Solomon of the temple would become an idolater? He once knelt and spread out his hands toward God in the sight of the people.
The idolatry was not the first move away from God. It grew out of earlier choices that at the time looked harmless, even successful.
J. N. DarbyAt first this neglect of the word appeared to have no bad effect. He grew rich, as though it were only the fulfilment of God's promise. But it soon led to a departure more serious in its nature and its consequences... It ended in open disobedience of the clearest and most essential requirements of God's word. The path of sin is slippery, and it is always walked with quickening steps. The reason is that the first sin tends to weaken in the soul the authority and power of the one thing that can keep us from committing still greater sins. That one thing is the word of God, along with the sense of His presence, which gives the word all its practical power over us.
The verse gives the reason God's anger burned: this man had heard from God twice, and on this very subject. Comfort was part of the trap.
Leslie M. GrantThe Lord's anger burned against this famous king. He turned against God, even though the Lord had appeared to him twice and had given him a clear command not to follow other gods. It seems unthinkable that a believer would sink to such a level as Solomon did, but wealth and ease can be a terrible snare even to one who is born of God.
Another writer turns the failure on the reader: watch the very thing God has singled out in you.
William KellyThe greater the privilege and the higher the honour, the deeper the shame... It is written for our wisdom, for our learning, for our warning, that we should beware of slipping in the very thing which God singles out in us. ... Solomon rested in the fruits God had given him. He enjoyed what came from God, but turned aside from the living source.
Long before Solomon, the law had named two things a king must not pile up. His famous wisdom did not stop him from doing both.
A J PollockWe find Solomon importing war horses from Egypt and multiplying wives. He had seven hundred wives who were princesses and three hundred concubines, and his wives turned away his heart. This went against the prohibition in Deuteronomy 17:16: "Only he must not acquire many horses for himself or cause the people to return to Egypt in order to acquire many horses... And he shall not acquire many wives for himself, lest his heart turn away." Wisdom did not keep Solomon, and it will not keep any one of us. But clinging to the Lord will.
God deals with His people under a holy government. Grace does not lift anyone out from under it.
Numerical Bible NotesGrace known by us in Christ does not deliver us from this holy government of God. Instead, it gives us a higher place of favour than faith had ever known before. So we have greater responsibility, and we come more directly under the action of such divine principles... David used the sword to carry out his own sinful will, and the sword never left his house. Solomon mixed with foreigners, and his heart was led astray. Enemies then rose up from the very places he had drawn on to please himself.
Solomon's fall is not the end of the kingdom's story. Another King will hold the throne.
H. L. RossierAs far as man is concerned, this is the end of the kingdom. But what a prospect for the future! ... The kingdom of the Divine Solomon will reappear like the sun shining in its strength. It will never again depend on the fallible obedience of man. It will rest on the unfailing responsibility of the King whom God will anoint on Zion, the mountain of His holiness.
- Heart first. The chapter repeats it: his wives turned his heart. The idols came later, once the affections had moved.
- Step by step. The ruin grew from an earlier neglect of God's word that seemed to cost him nothing. Each step made the next easier.
- Twice. God measures the fall by the light given: two appearances, a plain command on this very point, and honour that deepens the shame.
- Wisdom fails. The wisest man alive fell where he was strongest. Only dependence on the Lord keeps anyone.
- Government stands. Grace does not lift a believer out of God's government. But the kingdom's future rests on a King who cannot fail.
and had commanded him concerning this thing, not to go after other gods; but he kept not what Jehovah had commanded.
God was angry with Solomon, and this verse gives the reason. God Himself had warned him about this very thing. Solomon had heard God's voice twice, and still did not keep what God commanded. How did a man who knew so much come to obey so little?
One writer traces the three times God spoke to Solomon, and how the tone changed each time.
W. W. FeredayOnce more, and for the last time, Solomon heard the voice of his God. When He appeared to him in Gibeon, He said, "Ask what I shall give you." He was pleased with the young king's reply (1 Kings 3). In Jerusalem He spoke to him with encouragement and warning (1 Kings 9). Now He could only pass sentence on a servant who had been so unfaithful. The kingdom of Israel was now to be broken up. As a witness for God it had become worthless.
The phrase "concerning this thing" points to a specific instruction, not a general one. Solomon had both the written law and God's own voice on the subject.
Eugene P. Vedder Jr.God had given warnings and clear instructions in the Law. He had also appeared to Solomon Himself twice, and had commanded him not to go after other gods. Wife after wife seems to have persuaded him to build a high place for her idol... Before long these high places defiled "the mountain east of Jerusalem," the Mount of Olives. They stayed there 350 years, until the reign of Josiah.
The collapse was not sudden. It began with small departures from God's word that seemed to do no harm at the time.
J. N. DarbyAt first this neglect of the word seemed to do no harm. He grew rich, as though God were only keeping His promise. But it soon led to a more serious departure, both in itself and in what came of it... and at last to open disobedience of the clearest and most basic commands. The slippery path of sin is always walked with quicker and quicker steps. The first sin weakens in the soul the authority and power of the one thing that can keep us from still greater sins — the word of God.
Wisdom did not keep Solomon safe, because his failure lay somewhere other than the mind.
Eugene P. Vedder Jr.One good clue lies in a proverb of his, where he tells us, "Whoever trusts in his own mind is a fool" (Prov. 28:26). God had given His people clear instructions that their kings were not to take many wives. Solomon... took 700 wives, princesses, and 300 concubines besides these! Perhaps he told himself that some of these marriages served the interests of the state. But God tells us plainly that "Solomon clung to these in love." Solomon's problem was a matter of the heart! He disobeyed, and his heart was turned away.
Older translations read "trusts in his own heart" in that proverb — the word this writer picks up.
God's anger did not mean He had given Solomon up. One writer even finds comfort in it.
William KellyThere is a little comfort for us here — almost the only comfort in all we are told of king Solomon — and it is this: God disciplined him. He did not merely let the fruit of his evil, the results of his folly, show up in his family. He disciplined Solomon himself, in his own lifetime. This is His way with His own people. In some cases it is almost the only hope you have that a person is a child of God: God does not let the evil pass, but deals with it now, in this world. Those God passes over in spite of evil are clearly waiting to be condemned with the world. But those who are guilty and are dealt with now are the objects of God's fatherly care.
Reproof did not do for Solomon what it had done for his father.
Leslie M. GrantWhen David sinned against the Lord, he repented deeply as soon as the Lord reproved him. God reproved Solomon too, but nothing suggests that he ever repented.
Solomon's failure was a lost love, and that danger reaches past kings and past the young.
An Outline of Sound WordsWhen Solomon turned from God, he left his first love. He gave the idols of the nations the place in his heart that belonged to God. There is always the danger, even in old age, that something will push out of our hearts the love we owe to God. That is why it is written, "Little children, keep yourselves from idols" (1 John 5:21).
- Light given. God appeared to Solomon twice and named this exact sin. His anger matched the light Solomon had.
- Word neglected. The slide began with small steps that seemed harmless while his riches grew. Each one loosened the word's hold on him.
- Heart turned. The problem was never a lack of wisdom but a lack of guarded love — he clung in love to what God had forbidden.
- Anger that chastens. God did not let the evil pass. He dealt with Solomon in his own lifetime — a mark of fatherly care, not rejection.
- No repentance. David repented under reproof; Solomon, so far as the record shows, did not — so keep your heart, even in old age.
And Jehovah said to Solomon, Forasmuch as this is done by thee, and thou hast not kept my covenant and my statutes which I commanded thee, I will certainly rend the kingdom from thee, and will give it to thy servant
Solomon's reign ends with a verdict, not a gift. God will tear the kingdom away and give it to one of Solomon's own servants. What is he charged with? Why does a whole nation pay? And is there any mercy left in it?
God's complaint is not vague. It names a covenant and laws Solomon knew and ignored. One writer shows how far the collapse had already gone.
Hamilton SmithTurn to 1 Kings 10 and 11 and you find King Solomon breaking down at every point. He collects many horses. He sends the people back to Egypt. He takes many wives for himself, and piles up silver and gold in great amounts. And though much is told us of Solomon's riches, wisdom and splendour, we are never told that he read the law of the Lord.
Before the kingdom was torn, something else was. His wives moved his heart first, and one writer explains why a heart never stays empty.
Leslie M. GrantHis heart was turned away from the Lord first, so when he grew old he gave in to the pull of idols. Our hearts are not empty spaces. If we push the Lord out of our hearts, they will soon take hold of some false substitute. These wives had many substitutes, and they could persuade Solomon that they were attractive.
God had spoken to Solomon twice before, at Gibeon and at Jerusalem. This third time the tone has changed.
W. W. FeredayOnce more, and for the last time, Solomon heard the voice of his God. When He appeared to him at Gibeon, He said, "Ask what I shall give you," and He was pleased with the young king's reply (1 Kings 3). In Jerusalem He spoke to him in words of encouragement and warning (1 Kings 9). Now He could only pass sentence on His shamefully unfaithful servant... The kingdom of Israel should now be broken up. As a witness for God it had become worthless.
Solomon's father sinned too. The difference is what he did next.
Leslie M. GrantWhen the Lord rebuked David for his sin, David repented deeply. God rebuked Solomon too, but nothing shows that he repented.
Later events give the servant a name, and show the split that followed.
A. J. PollockThe Lord was angry with him, and no wonder: He would tear the kingdom from him and give it to his servant (1 Kings 11:11). This came to pass, not in Solomon's reign, for God had respect to his father, David. It came in the reign of his very foolish son Rehoboam. The kingdom was split: ten tribes went with Jeroboam, Solomon's servant, and Judah and Benjamin stayed with Rehoboam. It was a big price to pay for his folly and sin.
Solomon heard the sentence and tried to stop it. That put him in company he would not have chosen.
The Bible TreasuryHe has become like Saul. Saul tried to kill David because God had given him the kingdom. In the same way Solomon tried to kill his servant Jeroboam, because God had given him ten tribes. In both cases it was rebellion against the decree of God.
The word "surely" sounds final. Yet the next verses soften both the timing and the extent. Neither mercy is owed to Solomon.
Leslie M. GrantYet the Lord would not do this while Solomon was alive, because He respected Solomon's father David. Solomon's son would suffer the shame of a broken kingdom (v.12). Even so, God would leave one tribe to that son — again for David's sake, not for Solomon's sake... This mercy was also for Jerusalem's sake. God's choice of that city stood, despite the failure and disobedience of all Israel.
This verse gives one cause for the split. It is not the whole account.
James BoydTen of the tribes of Israel were torn from Rehoboam. In 1 Kings 11:11 we are told it was for the sin of Solomon. But verse 33 of the same chapter says it was for the idolatry of the people. And in chapter 12 we find the triggering cause was the harsh way Rehoboam met the people... The fact is that the sin of any one of the three named was enough by itself to bring all the harm that was done. So the responsibility is left at the door of each. Let me say again, though, that this judgment is only about God's government in this life. It does not always reach into eternity.
The story ends here only if the throne depends on men like Solomon.
H. L. RossierAs far as man is concerned, this is the end of the kingdom. But what a prospect for the future! ...the kingdom of the Divine Solomon will reappear like the sun shining in its strength. It will never again depend on the fallible obedience of man. It will rest on the King whom God will anoint on Zion, the mountain of His holiness, and He never fails in what He has taken up.
- Heart first. Nothing was torn from Solomon until something was turned in him; a heart emptied of God fills with substitutes.
- Charge next. God names the failure plainly: a covenant and laws Solomon was given and never kept.
- Sentence follows. The God who once said "Ask what I shall give you" now only pronounces judgment, and Solomon, unlike David, never repents.
- Mercy remains. The tearing is delayed past his lifetime and one tribe is spared — for David's sake and Jerusalem's, not his own.
- Hope outlasts it. One writer sees the broken kingdom pointing on to a King whose reign never rests on man's obedience.
notwithstanding in thy days I will not do it, for David thy father's sake; I will rend it out of the hand of thy son;
Solomon's long slide into idolatry ends with God speaking to him again — no longer with promises, but with a sentence: God will tear the kingdom away. Verse 12 holds a strange mercy inside that sentence: the loss is real, but God delays it, and the reason has nothing to do with Solomon himself.
God had told Solomon what turning to other gods would cost. Solomon ignored the warning, and God's own word bound Him to act.
Eugene P. Vedder Jr.God spoke to Solomon again, but now in judgment. He had warned Solomon what would come of turning away from following Him and keeping His commandments. If he served and worshipped idols instead, the result would be ruin. He must now act in faithfulness to His word. In Galatians 6:7 we read, "Do not be deceived: God is not mocked, for whatever one sows, that will he also reap." Solomon's wisdom, wealth and power could not turn aside God's just judgment. The kingdom would be torn from him and given to his servant.
The words "I will not do it in your days" sound like leniency toward Solomon. The reason attached to them says otherwise.
A J PollockGod acted in judgment as He must always do when the believer knowingly breaks Scripture. God delayed carrying out that judgment, not for Solomon's sake, but for his father David's.
Solomon keeps his throne whole; his son inherits the fracture. God grants even the one tribe left over on the same borrowed credit.
Leslie M. GrantYet the Lord would not do this while Solomon was living, because the Lord respected Solomon's father David. But Solomon's son would suffer the humiliation of a broken kingdom (v.12). God would still leave one tribe to that son — again for the sake of David, not for Solomon's sake. Judah was that tribe, though Benjamin, very small and weak, was included with Judah.
This pattern is not confined to kings, and it has a boundary worth knowing.
James BoydIn the government of God, children have to suffer for the sins of their parents, and nations for the sins of their rulers. People may complain about this and call it injustice. But the fact remains. If a man wastes his inheritance and abuses his body, his children will suffer for it in poverty and weakness. But this does not extend beyond the present life, and the sorrows here on earth are short-lived. No one will undergo the judgment of hell for the sins of others, but only for those he has committed himself.
God sets two limits on the loss — one on its timing, one on its size. Both trace back to the same source.
Eugene P. Vedder Jr.God always acts in faithfulness to His word and in keeping with His character. So here God holds back from carrying out His judgment during Solomon's lifetime. He does this in line with His word to David, whom He calls "My servant," and for the sake of Jerusalem, the city He had chosen. God also softens its severity. He would not take away the entire kingdom. He would give Solomon's son one tribe, and so keep a lamp for David always in Jerusalem.
Solomon could have rested in that promise. Instead he went after the servant God had named.
Truth & TestimonyNow Solomon faced another promise of God. This time God had promised Jeroboam that part of the kingdom would be his. God had assured him, "Yet for the sake of David your father I will not do it in your days." Solomon would not rest in that. Like Herod in a later day, he took the law into his own hands and tried to kill Jeroboam. But of course nothing could frustrate God's promises. Jeroboam fled into Egypt and stayed there until Solomon died.
When the split came, it looked like one king's blunder. Verse 12 had already named the deeper cause.
An Outline of Sound WordsThe obvious and immediate cause of the division was the foolishness of the king. He rejected the advice of the elders. But the underlying cause was Solomon's idolatry... The kingdom was never reunited, and will not be until the Lord comes.
- Sown — Solomon was warned. He sowed idolatry and reaped a torn kingdom. Wisdom, wealth and power could not turn it aside.
- Delayed — the mercy in "I will not do it in your days" was real, but God credited it to David, not to Solomon.
- Softened — the same reason that delayed the judgment also shrank it. God left one tribe and kept a lamp for David in Jerusalem.
- Inherited — the son bore the broken kingdom his father earned. Such consequences run through families and nations. But they belong to this life, not to eternity.
- Wasted — God gave Solomon a lifetime of grace. He spent it hunting Jeroboam instead of resting in God's word. The split he tried to stop came anyway, and it has never healed.