The children of Reuben and the Gadites and half the tribe of Manasseh, of valiant men, men who carried shield and sword, drawing the bow and skilful in war, were forty-four thousand seven hundred and sixty, able to go forth to war.
This chapter lists the tribes who settled east of the Jordan: Reuben, Gad, and half of Manasseh. This verse counts their fighting men. Why does a book of family lists pause to number an army? And why did these tribes need one?
The chapter shows Reuben pushing to enlarge his borders. One writer compares that drive with Caleb's and finds a different motive behind it.
H. L. RossierIt is true that the text stresses Reuben's energy to enlarge his borders (v. 10). But this is no longer the virtue we have seen in Caleb, which sprang from faith alone. Reuben's activity has a motive that is merely human and earthly: "Their cattle were multiplied in the land of Gilead" (v. 9).
The shields and bows match the map. These tribes stood between Israel and every enemy that came from the east.
Morrish Bible DictionaryBeing on the east of Jordan, Gad, with Reuben and Manasseh, would have to bear the shock of the enemies that attacked Israel on the east (1 Chr. 5:18-22). They were a warlike tribe, suited to such an exposed position.
That position also carried a cost. One writer treats the Jordan as the edge of the promised land, and reads their choice to settle outside it as a loss.
Morrish Bible DictionaryThe Jordan may also be seen as the boundary of the promised land. So the two and a half tribes who stayed on the east of it stopped short of their privileges. They are a picture of many Christians who do not accept by faith the heavenly portion God intends for them, a portion reached through death and resurrection. Such Christians are more open to the attacks of the enemy, as the two and a half tribes were — they were the first to be carried into captivity.
This verse counts trained men. The verses that follow credit the win over the Hagrites to something else: a cry to God during the fight, and God's own character.
H. L. RossierThese two and a half tribes waged war against the Hagrites, Jetur, Naphish, and Nodab... "for they cried out to God in the battle, and He granted their urgent plea because they trusted in Him" (vv. 19-20). God granted their prayers just as He had answered the prayer of a single man, Jabez. "They trusted in Him." The God of grace owed it to His own character to answer them, however guilty they were when it came to the unity of the people of God. So, despite the ruin, grace always responds to faith.
The same writer holds two things together here: God judges the flesh, and God answers faith.
H. L. RossierThe flesh is condemned. The captivity is the consequence of its independence, but faith is answered. God is not only a God of government, who gives to each person according to his responsibility; He is also a God of grace, who cannot deny His character. In verse 22 we read, "The war was of God." He had stirred up the trouble to exercise the faith and confidence of His people, so that He could then answer them.
Long name-lists can look like filler. One writer picks this war out of them as proof of the power of faith, and adds a second case beside it.
C KnappThe sons of Reuben, too, with their allies who overcame the Hagrites, are cited as another instance of the power of faith (chap. 5:18-20). Nor does God forget Zelophehad, the man who had no sons to inherit after him. He claimed a portion for his daughters, and learned that the strength of the Lord is made perfect in weakness.
Victory did not secure their future. The next verses name what went wrong, and it was not a shortage of soldiers.
H. L. RossierIn His grace God had prospered the men of Manasseh: "They were many" (v. 23). But God's favour had won them blessings, and those blessings turned them away from Him instead of drawing them closer: "And they transgressed against the God of their fathers" (v. 25).
Others draw the practical point from where they chose to live:
Samuel RidoutSettling down in the world, allowing selfish interests to dictate our path and testimony, is to open the gates for the enemy's assail.
- Position. They settled east of the Jordan and stopped short of their privileges. That choice left them exposed.
- Preparation. Their exposed border made them a warlike people — 44,760 trained men was the cost of the ground they chose.
- Prayer. Trained men still cried out to God in the battle, and He granted their plea because they trusted Him.
- Purpose. The war itself was of God, arranged to exercise their faith so that He could answer it.
- Peril. Numbers, land and wealth did not hold them. They turned from the God of their fathers, and were carried into captivity first.
And they made war with the Hagarites, with Jetur, and Naphish, and Nodab;
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
and they were helped against them, and the Hagarites were delivered into their hand, and all that were with them; for they cried to God in the battle, and he was intreated of them, because they put their trust in him.
The men who won this battle lived east of the Jordan, outside the land God promised Israel. So why did He answer their cry in the middle of the fight, when their own position was a compromise?
Most of Chronicles is lists of names. Now and then the record stops to mark where God worked in a life. Older translations of this verse say God "was entreated of them," where the ESV says "he granted their urgent plea."
C KnappIt is sweet and strengthening to the soul to trace out the brief notes of what divine grace had done in one person and another, as they walked their often lowly ways with faith at work and conscience active. If this were only a human book, those notes would seem out of place among long lists of names… The sons of Reuben, too, with their allies, overcame the Hagarites when "they cried to God in the battle, and He was entreated of them, because they put their trust in Him." That stands as another instance of the power of faith.
Reuben, Gad and half of Manasseh settled east of the Jordan because the grazing suited their herds. One writer is blunt about what that cost.
C. H. MackintoshTheir promise to cross the Jordan, ready armed, ahead of their brothers, drew a kind of consent from Moses. It seemed an extraordinary display of unselfishness and energy to leave all their loved ones behind and cross the Jordan only to fight for their brothers. But where had they left those loved ones? They had left them short of the divine mark. They had robbed them of a place and a portion in the true land of promise. That was the inheritance God had spoken of to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. And for what? Just to get good pasture for their cattle.
God answered these men, and the reason given is their trust.
H. L. Rossier"They put their trust in Him"; the God of grace owed it to His own character to answer them, however guilty they might be about the unity of the people of God. So, despite the ruin, grace always responds to faith. This is one of the distinctive marks of the whole of these books of Chronicles. The flesh is condemned, and the captivity is the result of its independence. But God answers faith. He is a God of government, who repays man according to his responsibility. He is also a God of grace, who cannot deny His character. In verse 22 we read, "The war was of God." He had stirred up the trouble to exercise the faith and confidence of His people, so that He could then answer them.
The wording points to something about God, not only about them: prayer moves Him. One writer recalls a time when God's people fasted and begged for His protection, then turns the phrase on us.
A J PollockMay we not remind ourselves that the God of Israel is our God too, that He is unchanged in His power and in His interest in His own? Their side was to fast and beg God for His help and protection. God's side is expressed in the words, "He was entreated of us." Will not our God be entreated by us? Have we not a marvellous opportunity in these days of weakness? We talk about weakness and say too little about God's almighty power and lasting interest in His own.
They cried out during the fight, not before it only. One writer sees God's purpose in that, and an answer for Christians who keep losing the same struggle.
J T MawsonThey were never equal to their enemies by their own strength. God made them like that, so that in every time of stress they would depend on Him. He was their refuge and resource and strength… And God always responded to their appeal. And will He disappoint us if we take up this stand in faith? Let us test Him and see. How fierce are the struggles some Christians face! They want to do right and to overcome when strong temptations press on them. They long for a victorious life, but they seem to long in vain. They find the enemy too strong for them, so they are discouraged and ready to give up the fight.
- The cry. They called on God while the fight was still going on. That dependence in the middle of the battle was the turning point.
- The criers. They were men who had settled short of the land for the sake of pasture, and had left their families outside the true inheritance.
- The ground. God answered because they trusted Him. Grace responds to faith even when a person's position is compromised, because God cannot deny His own character.
- The two hands. He governs, repaying people for what they do; the captivity later proved it. He also gives grace. Both are true of Him at once.
- The invitation. He answered prayer then, and He has not changed. Our side is to ask; His side is to answer. He will not disappoint faith that tests Him.
And they took away their cattle their camels fifty thousand, and two hundred and fifty thousand sheep, and two thousand asses, and a hundred thousand human souls.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
For there fell down many slain, for the war was of God. And they dwelt in their stead until the captivity.
This verse ends a battle report, and it raises a hard question. How does God hand victory to tribes who had settled east of the Jordan, outside the land He promised them?
The verse does not say the tribes were strong or well-armed. It says the war belonged to God. One writer reads that as God Himself setting the whole conflict going:
H. L. RossierIn verse 22 we read, "The war was of God." He had stirred up the difficulty to exercise the faith and confidence of His people, so that He could then answer them.
Their position made such raids almost routine. The tribes east of the Jordan stood between Israel and the desert peoples:
Morrish Bible DictionaryLiving east of the Jordan, this tribe, with Reuben and Manasseh, had to take the full force of the enemies who attacked Israel from the east. They were a warlike tribe, suited to such an exposed position.
The victory of verse 22 followed their trust in God. Rossier says His own character obliged Him to answer it:
H. L. Rossier"They put their trust in Him." The God of grace owed it to His own character to answer them, however guilty they were when it came to the unity of the people of God. So, despite the ruin, grace always responds to faith. This is one of the marks of the whole of these books of Chronicles. The flesh is condemned. The captivity is the result of its independence. But faith is answered. God is not only a God of government, who repays each man according to his responsibility. He is also a God of grace, who cannot deny His character.
These men were not where God wanted them, and He still answered them. Another writer turns that into a rebuke:
The Bible TreasuryGod always hears those who put their trust in Him and call on Him in time of danger. He hears them even when they are in a wrong position, and forget Him in practice while things around them seem prosperous. And is not this one of His gracious ways of rebuking our unfaithfulness?
Reuben, Gad and half of Manasseh chose the fertile land east of the Jordan. They took it instead of the land God had promised:
The Bible TreasuryThe fertility of the land east of the Jordan attracted them, and they paid no regard to the promise. This was not falling in the wilderness, but it was coming short of the grace of God. To their eyes the land of their choice might have every advantage. It was fertile and suitable for "much cattle". But it was not the promised land.
A real victory east of the Jordan is still not a share in what God was doing inside the land:
The Bible TreasuryBecause they were outside the promised land, they lost the special privileges of the temple. They also lost the awareness, which the other tribes might have had, that the power Jehovah displayed in the battles with the Canaanites was for them… They became mere onlookers of the triumphs of Israel. The helpful lessons connected with Ai, with Gibeon, and so on, were only second-hand to them… But God's purpose was — and is — to establish all the people of Israel in that land. Humanly speaking, these tribes frustrated that purpose. God's grace rises above man's failure. He will fulfil His purpose, and prove that where sin abounded, grace abounds even more.
(Ai and Gibeon were early episodes in Israel's conquest of Canaan.)
The verse ends with a time limit on their stay. Their history runs from a famous victory to deportation. The turn comes with one charge in verse 25, quoted here in an older translation:
The Bible TreasuryTheir beginning seemed fair; there were brave men among them. They were well known, but there was this fatal charge against them: "And they transgressed." They were shut out from the special blessing of the land. How great their loss! The consequences were both moral and judicial. They went after the gods of the people of the land — they became idol worshippers. That was the moral consequence of their position. The judicial consequence is that the "God of Israel" brought the king of Assyria upon them. He carried them into captivity, far from the land that they valued above God's land.
- Cause. The conflict was no accident of border life. God stirred it up to exercise His people's faith and confidence, so that He could answer them.
- Cry. They called on Him in the time of danger. The God of grace answers trust, because He cannot deny His own character.
- Grace. Their wrong position did not block the answer. God hears those who trust Him even when they are where they should not be. That kindness is itself a rebuke.
- Cost. Grace gave them the battle, but not the blessing of the land. Outside it they only watched Israel's great victories, and the lessons reached them second-hand.
- End. "Until the exile" caps the whole story. A fair start, brave men, one fatal charge, then captivity far from the land they preferred to God's. Yet God's purpose to settle all Israel in His land still stands.