1 Chronicles 11:10–47

1 Chronicles 11:10 · Darby

And these are the chief of the mighty men whom David had, who shewed themselves valiant with him in his kingdom, with all Israel, to make him king, according to the word of Jehovah concerning Israel.

This verse names the men who stood behind David when the crown came to him. Their support carries out a word God had already spoken about Israel. Two questions follow. Why does Chronicles put this roll of honour at the start of the reign? And what turned ordinary fighters into "mighty men"?

Why the list comes first

Chronicles and 2 Samuel list the same men in different places. In Samuel the list closes the reign. Here it opens the reign, and one writer draws a point out of that.

This account lists David's mighty men at the beginning (vv. 10-47), while 2 Samuel 23 lists them at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom... They carry out the plans God had made known beforehand. Our chapter refers to 81 mighty men; 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. There they appear as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our present chapter they have only to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed. They cannot do other than support a kingship that came out of the counsels of God Himself.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Where their strength came from

Scripture calls them mighty, but they did not start that way. Many had served under Saul with no such record. The ESV says they "gave him strong support"; older translations read "showed themselves valiant with him." Their backing took the form of courage.

Faith and the display of God's power tend to bring out the energy and strength of those who join themselves to it. The man God is with attracts those God is working with. Their energy grows in proportion to the display of His presence and favour. Many of these had been with Saul, but when they were with him they were not mighty men... When God acts in power, He gives strength to the weak, and by the energy of faith and of His Spirit He produces an army of heroes.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Their beginnings were lower still. The first of them attached themselves to David when there was nothing to gain by it.

The foremost of these worthies joined David while he was a fugitive and an outcast (1 Chron. 12:1-22). 1 Samuel 22:2 gives their origin, one instance among many of God taking up the despised of men and exalting them.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Two kinds of service

One commentator notices who stepped forward to win the captaincy, and who held back.

It is remarkable that Joab steps forward — not Abishai, not any one of those most honourable three, not Eleazar or Jashobeam, or any of the others... The truth is that Joab was an ambitious man. He did not care to expose himself more than was necessary; but when there was anything to be got, Joab was the man. Joab was ready for action then, not to suffer but to gain. So he goes forward, takes the stronghold, and becomes chief.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The men named from verse 10 onward are the opposite case. One line draws the contrast:

Then follow the true worthies of David, the true warriors, not for what was to be got, but for David.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The deeds as a preview

The chapter tells their exploits at length. One writer explains what those deeds point forward to.

These great acts are only the natural consequences of the presence of His power. He is giving samples, so to speak, of what the power and the glory will be when He Himself takes the kingdom. Then greater deeds will be done.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

The share in the kingdom

One writer ties their place in the kingdom to the years before it:

The mighty men were with David in the days of his rejection. They passed through the sorrows and the conflicts with him, and are therefore privileged to be with him in his kingdom.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

One writer turns this to our own day:

And is there no voice in this for us today? Our Lord is now rejected, but the crowning day is coming by and by. Now is the time to show which side we are on... Devotedness is not seen in waiting for tasks that will bring us into publicity, into work that is spectacular. It is seen in a readiness to do the humblest, most menial work that needs doing in the service of the Lord.

Modernised from A. J. PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- Word first. The kingdom does not rest on the men. They only acknowledge what God had already settled, and their support confirms a throne that came out of His counsels.

- Weak first. They joined a fugitive and an outcast — an instance of God taking up the despised of men and exalting them.

- Strength given. Some had served Saul with no such record. When God acts in power He gives strength to the weak and makes an army of heroes.

- Motive tested. Joab moved when there was something to be got; the worthies fought not for gain but for David.

- Kingdom shared. They stayed with him through the sorrows, so they share his kingdom. The crowning day of our rejected Lord is still ahead.

1 Chronicles 11:11 · Darby

And this is the number of the mighty men whom David had Jashobeam, the son of Hachmoni, the chief of the captains; he brandished his spear against three hundred, slain [by him] at one time.

This verse opens the list of David's mighty men. The first name on it is Jashobeam, who faced three hundred enemies alone. Two questions come with him. Why does Scripture keep such a record at all? And why do the details differ from the list in 2 Samuel 23?

Where the list stands in Chronicles

The same men appear in 2 Samuel 23, but at the close of David's reign. One writer draws a lesson from where each list stands.

David's mighty men are listed at the beginning of this account (vv. 10-47), while in 2 Samuel 23 they are listed at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom. They showed themselves valiant with him to make him king, so carrying out the plans God had already made known. … In 2 Samuel 23 they are listed as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our chapter they have only to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed. They can do nothing other than support a kingship that came out of the counsels of God Himself.

Modernised from Henri L. RossierOriginal wording

Where their strength came from

Jashobeam's feat is startling. The record traces the valour of the whole company back to one cause.

God at once surrounds David with mighty men of valour. And the tribes of Israel send their thousands, "men of war that could keep rank," or as we would say, well disciplined. Who had disciplined these men? Just before, they had abandoned their cities and hidden themselves in fear of the Philistines. God's chosen man was there, the one anointed to be king over Israel, and the kingdom was turned to him. This is the reason for their sudden gift of valour and might. It also explains some of the wonderful deeds of the famous men whom the Holy Spirit names.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

The leading names had joined David while he was still hunted and homeless. Here is "an instance among many of God's taking up the despised of men and exalting them" (The Bible Treasury).

The name and the differing numbers

"Hachmonite" means son of Hachmoni. The verse in 2 Samuel gives a different name and a different number. Commentators differ on how to account for it. (Older translations render "chief of the three" as "chief of the captains.")

In 1 Chronicles 11:11 the chief of the captains is Jashobeam a Hachmonite, or son of Hachmoni… It is difficult to reconcile the two passages. Some think that Jashobeam and Joshebbassebet are the same name, one being altered by the copyist. Some take the passage in Samuel to be incorrect. They make "Adino the Eznite" not a proper name but "he swung his spear." … The two passages may refer to different persons. Note that Jashobeam is said to have killed three hundred men, and Adino eight hundred. The first is also named in connection with David's coming to power. The second is named with "the last words of David." So Jashobeam may have died and Adino become chief in his place.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Others weigh the wording itself. In that one verse of 2 Samuel "almost every word is in question." The phrase "he brandished his spear" is the clearer reading here in Chronicles (Numerical Bible Notes).

The secret behind the spear

The feat made Jashobeam famous. It was not the root of his greatness, and not the end of his story.

He lifted up his spear against three hundred of David's enemies, and killed them in one tremendous fight. This is the triumph that brought him into distinction, and he became "the chief of the captains." Still, the true secret of his success was his attachment to David. He had shared David's rejection and sufferings. Afterwards we find him still with David in the glory of his kingdom… There may be something distinctive in our service for the Anointed of God now, as there will be in the kingdom rewards later on. But faithful and fruitful service comes only as the love of Christ constrains us to cleave to Him.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

What ranks highest

Later in the chapter, three of David's men do nothing more than bring him a drink of water. That small act, not any battlefield record, drew the highest praise.

None of these spectacular things did they aim at. They simply got a drink of water for David. How was it that such a simple bit of service carried such appreciation? The answer is that it was an act of supreme devotedness to David.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

That God bothered to write any of it down is itself the point:

God loves to mention what is an honour to His people; and so, after each of their names, we find a record of their deeds. The Lord will do this and more for those who now and always have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- Cause. The men became mighty because God's anointed king was among them. Their courage dated from the day the kingdom turned to David.

- Company. The foremost of them joined him while he was still a fugitive; God takes up the despised and lifts them into honour.

- Chief. Jashobeam's three hundred won him first place. But his real distinction lay elsewhere. He shared David's rejection before he shared his throne.

- Text. The name and number in 2 Samuel 23 differ. The explanations offered are a copyist's slip, a disputed phrase, or two different men. Commentators do not agree.

- Crown. The highest praise in the chapter went to three men who fetched water, not to the largest tally of enemies. God writes down and rewards devotedness, not achievement.

1 Chronicles 11:12 · Darby

And after him, Eleazar the son of Dodo, the Ahohite; he was one of the three mighty men.

One line of a battle list names Eleazar, son of Dodo the Ahohite. It sets him second among David's three mighty men. Behind that short entry lie a stand against the Philistines and a hand that would not let go of its sword. It also raises a question: why does God write such names down at all?

The Names Themselves

Each name in this verse carries a meaning. One writer gives them all, then points out a puzzle. This account does not match the one in 2 Samuel 23 at every point.

The second name is that of Eleazar ("help of God"), the son of Dodo ("his Beloved"), the Ahohite (brotherly?). Here, too, Chronicles differs from Samuel. He is not presented here as only one of three mighty men who defied the Philistines with David. If he were, you would expect the other two to appear in the action. Chronicles simply presents him as being "with David at Pas-dammim, and the Philistines assembled there" for battle. Here, however, Chronicles seems to have a gap in the text, which as a result credits Eleazar with the action of Shammah, whom it leaves out.

Modernised from Frederick W GrantOriginal wording

Commentators differ here. Another writer takes the victory at Pas-dammim as Eleazar's own, saying it is "divinely put to Eleazar's credit."

With David

Others ran from that fight. Eleazar stayed. One writer explains why, and then draws meaning from the name of the ground he held.

The two words "with David" explain why he was so successful. Others might flee in a time of stress, but not Eleazar — he was with David at "Pas-dammim," which means "the boundary of blood." There David first defeated the enemies of the God of Israel and killed the giant. It speaks of Calvary, where Christ overthrew the giant enemy that would have held us in misery for ever, and saved us with an everlasting salvation. To serve Him well we must always remember the "boundary of blood" — "the blood of His cross." It is the ground of our eternal triumph. It divides us from all that is against our Lord Jesus Christ.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The Weary Hand and the Sword

The fuller account of this fight stands in 2 Samuel. One writer reads it, and the meaning of Eleazar's name, as pointing past the man to God.

He struck them down "until his hand was weary, and his hand clung to the sword. And the LORD brought about a great victory" (2 Samuel 23:9-10). His very name, "God is help," turns us from the man to God. What could he do single-handed against the host of the enemy? His arm grows weary, but the weary hand clings to the good sword. We see no longer the feeble arm of man, but the power of God behind that weary arm, carving out victory with that sword. The man has become identified with the sword, and God can use such a one.

Modernised from Frederick W GrantOriginal wording

Second Place Without Envy

Eleazar comes second in this list, not first. One writer treats that order as the Lord's own gift, and asks what envy would look like in such a place.

David's mighty men were given the privilege of owning the claims of the Lord while they fought under His banner. They received their promotion at His hands, as a token of His favour, and that favour let them share in His victories. We cannot imagine for a moment that Eleazar would envy Adino, or that Shammah claimed to be equal with Eleazar. What but spiritual pride could make a servant want the words "After me" next to his own name instead of "After him"? If the same spirit of yielding were seen more among the people of God, and each counted others better than themselves, what a reproduction of Christ there would be in this world while He is away!

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Why the Deeds Are Written Down

No one was keeping records on that battlefield. The names survive because the Holy Spirit wrote them down, and one writer points from that to a coming day.

Because they belonged to David, his men had to endure much toil and weariness. But love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and deeds were written down and faithfully remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten... These acts may not be seen, known, or thought of by men; but Jesus knows them, and will publicly declare them from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known the acts of David's worthies if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- With. The secret of Eleazar's strength is not his skill but his place: he stayed with David when others fled.

- Where. He stood at "the boundary of blood," where David had won before. It speaks of the cross, which divides us from everything against Christ.

- Weak. His name means "God is help," and his tired hand shows the power was God's, not his.

- Welded. The hand that clings to the sword becomes one with it; such a man God can use.

- Written. No one kept a record in the field, yet the deed stands in Scripture — and Jesus will announce such service from His throne.

1 Chronicles 11:13 · Darby

He was with David at Pas-dammim, where the Philistines were gathered together to battle; and there was [there] a plot of ground full of barley; and the people had fled from before the Philistines.

Eleazar stands beside David at Pas-dammim while the Philistines gather for battle and the rest of Israel runs. Why was one small field of barley worth a battle, and where did one man's courage come from?

With David

One writer asks why Eleazar succeeded when others ran, and finds the answer in two words of the verse and in the name of the place.

God Himself credits this victory to Eleazar, and he was one of the first three of David's mighty men. But the two words "with David" explain why he was so successful. Others might flee when times are hard, but not Eleazar. He was with David at "Pas-dammim," which means "the boundary of blood." There David first defeated the enemies of the God of Israel and killed the giant. It speaks of Calvary. There Christ overthrew the giant enemy that would have held us in misery forever, and saved us with an everlasting salvation. To serve Him well we must always remember the "boundary of blood" — "the blood of His cross." It is the ground of our eternal triumph. It divides us from all that is against our Lord Jesus Christ.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The same place is called Ephes-dammim in 1 Samuel 17: "Place in Judah, the scene of the death of Goliath in the valley of Elah. 1 Sam. 17:1. Called PAS-DAMMIM in 1 Chr. 11:13."

When the people fled

The men ran. One writer sees the same thing happening today.

We too are living in a day when many have gone away. The world has seduced some, some have grown tired of the conflict, and some have just gone with the majority. How blessed if it can be said of us that we remained faithful to the Lord in the day of conflict and danger… It is not enough to enter the conflict God has called us to. We are to endure in it to the end. We are to be strong in the Lord and in the power of His might, and, having done all, to stand (Eph. 6:10-19).

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

A field of barley

Barley was the cheap grain, "used as food for horses, 1 Kings 4:28; and also for the food of man when wheat failed." So the prize looks small. One writer, commenting on the parallel scene in 2 Samuel where the crop is lentils, shows what was at stake.

What they were fighting over was "a plot of ground full of lentils." It was a very small part of the inheritance God had given Israel, but it held food for the people. The enemy wanted to take the field and its crop from them… Our inheritance and our "plot of ground" are heavenly. We must defend them, and our heavenly food too — the Word which God has entrusted to us… May we defend it fearlessly for the sake of the saints, for we are with David. Let us count on God who will work "a great deliverance."

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Chronicles and Samuel

Chronicles credits this stand to Eleazar; 2 Samuel 23 divides the deeds and adds Shammah. Commentators differ on how to account for it.

Chronicles leaves Shammah out and gives his deeds to Dodo's son, Eleazar. They were very likely both there, but I would doubt it was the same occasion. In 2 Samuel this is a raid for plunder; 1 Chronicles hardly reads that way. The wording, though, is almost the same.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Another reading treats the shorter account as missing a line: "Here, however, Chronicles seems to have a gap in the text, which therefore ascribes the action of Shammah (whom it omits) to Eleazar."

Named at the start of the reign

In 2 Samuel the list of the mighty men comes at the close of David's life. Chronicles puts it at the start of his reign, and one writer draws meaning from that.

Here they bring in the kingdom. They "showed themselves valiant with him in his kingdom, with all Israel, to make him king, according to the word of Jehovah concerning Israel" (v. 10). In this way they carried out the plans God had made known beforehand.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The lesson drawn from these names is a plain one: "Devotedness is not seen in waiting for tasks that will bring us into the public eye, or for work that is spectacular. It is seen in a readiness to do the humblest, most menial work that needs doing in the service of the Lord."

Summary

- With. Eleazar's strength came from his position, not his skill. He was with David, at the place of blood where the giant had already fallen.

- Stand. The verse records a retreat. The honour goes to the man who did not join it. God asks us to keep standing, not just to start.

- Guard. A barley field is a small thing, yet it held the people's food. The small patch God has entrusted to you is worth fighting for.

- Differ. Chronicles and Samuel tell the story differently, and commentators differ on whether it is two occasions or a gap in the text.

- Reward. Chronicles names these men at the start of the reign, as those whose valour brought the kingdom in. The humblest service now is what the record remembers.

1 Chronicles 11:14 · Darby

And they stood in the midst of the plot and delivered it, and smote the Philistines; and Jehovah wrought a great deliverance.

A patch of barley, a line of Philistines, an army in retreat — and when the fighting ends, the credit goes to God, not to the man who stood. Why does Scripture keep such a small field on record, and whose victory was it?

Standing Because They Were "With David"

Verse 13 places Eleazar with David at Pas-dammim. One writer makes those two words — "with David" — the whole explanation of the stand here.

"He was with David at Pas-dammim." When all "the people fled from before the Philistines," they took their stand in the middle of "a plot of ground full of barley." They defeated their enemies so completely that they delivered the field from them. God puts this victory to Eleazar's credit, and he was one of the first three of David's mighty men. But the two words "with David" explain why he was so successful. Others might flee in a time of stress, but not Eleazar. He was with David at "Pas-dammim," which means "the boundary of blood." There David first defeated the enemies of the God of Israel and killed the giant. It speaks of Calvary. There Christ overthrew the giant enemy that would have held us captive in misery for ever, and saved us with an everlasting salvation.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

A Small Field Worth Defending

The prize was farmland, not a city or a throne. One writer, on the same battle in 2 Samuel, weighs what that small field was worth.

The object they were contesting was "a plot of ground full of lentils," a very little part of the inheritance that God had given Israel, but one containing food for the people. The enemy was seeking to deprive them of the field and its crop. Shammah stood in the middle of the field and preserved it for God's people. This deed speaks to our consciences. Our inheritance and our "plot of ground" are heavenly. We must defend them, and our heavenly food too — the Word which God has entrusted to us. May we be like Shammah; may we defend it without fear for the sake of the saints, for we are with David. Let us count on God who will work "a great deliverance."

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Why the Account Differs From 2 Samuel

The account in 2 Samuel names Shammah. This one does not. Commentators differ on why. One thinks two different battles are in view.

Chronicles leaves Shammah out and credits his deeds to Eleazar, the son of Dodo. They were very likely both there, but I doubt it was the same occasion. In 2 Samuel this is a raid for plunder; in 1 Chronicles it hardly seems so. The wording, though, is almost the same.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Another writer points instead to a gap in the text of Chronicles.

Here Chronicles seems to have a gap in the text, so it credits Eleazar with what Shammah did and leaves Shammah out. Fighting alone, as the account here seems to show, he strikes the Philistines till his cramped hand sticks to his sword-hilt. The people, who were absent from the battle, returned only to the spoil. So Jehovah through him worked a great deliverance.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

The Name That Matters Most

The verse tells of one man's courage and then ends with God's name. (Older translations read "a great deliverance" where the ESV has "saved them by a great victory.") One writer takes that closing clause as the real secret of the whole episode.

After this comes a name far more important than all the rest, and with it the secret of the warrior's success: "And the LORD worked a great victory" (2 Sam. 23:8-12). This leaves His servants free to acknowledge Him as their Deliverer, and to give Him His due. It also shows us how He identifies Himself with His servants, and lends His strength to those who fight His battles against the enemy.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Others say the same thing in one line: the men were the instruments, but the deliverance was God's.

Eleazar and Shammah may be the instruments used of God, but it is the Lord who works the great deliverance.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

Those Who Came Back Only for the Spoil

Others reaped the fruit of a fight they never joined.

So it is now. At times almost all have turned away from standing for the truth. Then some brave servant of the Lord has stood against the enemy, his hand clinging to the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God, and has won a great victory. Many a child of God coming after has reaped precious fruit from it.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Deeds God Chose to Remember

Scripture keeps this small deed on record. One writer says why that matters.

God loves to mention what is an honour to His people; and so, after each of their names we find a record of their deeds. The Lord will do this and more for those who now and ever have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- With — the stand begins with being "with David." Nearness to the king, not natural courage, is why one man held ground the crowd left.

- Ground — what he defended was only a field, but it held the food of God's people. Small ground is worth defending when the enemy wants it.

- Stand — everyone else fled; he took his stand in the middle of the field and did not leave until he had struck the Philistines down.

- Saved — the verse ends with God's name, not the soldier's, leaving His servants free to own Him as their Deliverer.

- After — those who ran came back only for the spoil. One man's faithfulness still feeds believers who come later, and God keeps the record of it.

1 Chronicles 11:15 · Darby

And three of the thirty chiefs went down to the rock to David, to the cave of Adullam, when the army of the Philistines was encamped in the valley of Rephaim.

Three men leave the settled world behind. They go down to a rock and a cave, where the rejected king is hiding. A Philistine army holds the open valley. Everything that follows in the chapter grows out of this one choice of where to be.

Why the List Comes Early in Chronicles

The same list of mighty men appears in 2 Samuel, but in a different place in the story. That change of place changes the point.

This account lists David's mighty men at the beginning (vv. 10-47). 2 Samuel 23 lists them at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom. They showed themselves valiant with him in his kingdom, together with all Israel, to make him king. So they carried out the plans which God had already made known... Our chapter refers to 81 mighty men, 30 of them recorded without being named, while 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. There they are supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our present chapter they have only to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Two Kings, Two Addresses

Going down to the rock meant walking away from somewhere else. Israel had two men to choose between, and each had a different address.

The choice lay between Saul and David. Saul is a picture of the man ruled by his own flesh; David is a picture of Christ. Saul is in the palace. He sits on the throne. The kingdom is at his feet. David is in the cave of Adullam. A band of men has gathered round him. Affection draws them, and they are devoted to his cause.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

The list of those who came is also a list of those who did not. Jonathan, of Saul's own house, never came to the cave.

Now that David is the outcast one and hidden in the cave of Adullam, will Jonathan join him there, and own him in the day of his rejection? Sadly, in the record of those whose loyalty and devotedness drew them to David in the cave, Jonathan's name is missing! Saul, his house, and the city pulled the other way, and were too strong. The men who gathered to David in Adullam were, it is true, a mixed group; but they gathered to the right person, and in the right place, as the outcome proved. No matter where Jonathan was, he was not with David, and so he was not with God.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Harvest Time

The parallel account in 2 Samuel 23 notes the season when they came.

These three mighty men came to David at harvest time, to the cave of Adullam (13). It seems as if they left the world in the day of its plenty, to identify themselves with David in the day of his poverty and reproach.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Near Enough to Hear

The famous act of the next verses was only possible because of this one. Distance would have made them deaf.

There are a few, and only a few, who care so much for David that they will link their destiny with his. They do it at a moment when, to sight at least, all is as dark as dark can be... If they are to share his triumphs and honours later, they will share his reproach and shame now... They are in the place to know his wishes. Had they not been in the cave with David, they never would have heard his longing for water from the well of Bethlehem. And they never would have been in Adullam, if David had not himself eclipsed all else in their affections.

Modernised from W T TurpinOriginal wording

The Army in the Valley

The valley named in the verse was ground the enemy had taken.

This valley lies south of Jerusalem. There the Philistines gathered against Israel, and there David twice defeated them decisively. Older English translations twice call it the "valley of the giants" (Joshua 15:8; 18:16).

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Pollock says what that ground cost the three:

The Philistine armies stood in tight ranks between the stronghold and the well. The three did not stop to count what it would cost to satisfy David's desire.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Unnamed on Purpose

This story never gives the names of the three. There is a reason for that silence.

Why this remarkable omission of their names in the account of their exploit? It is because here it is no longer a matter of energy and perseverance, but one of the devotion of faith. And this devotion flows naturally from the hearts of servants who know and appreciate their Master. By its very nature devotion is something obscure. What man has the right to boast of devotion?

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Summary

- Cave — David is the true king, but rejected. Only those who go down to the cave share his place.

- Choice — Saul held the palace, David a hole in the ground. Devotion shows in which address you walk toward.

- Cost — They came at harvest, leaving the world at its most profitable to join David at his poorest.

- Closeness — Nearness makes service possible. Outside the cave, no one hears the King's longing.

- Crown — Chronicles lists these men at the start of the reign. The men of the cave bring in the kingdom God had already promised.

1 Chronicles 11:16 · Darby

And David was then in the stronghold; and the Philistines' garrison was then at Bethlehem.

This verse catches one moment from David's years in exile: the rightful king hides in a stronghold, while enemy troops hold the town where he was born. That one sentence sets up one of the most moving acts of loyalty in Scripture.

The picture in the verse

The two halves of the verse are a study in contrast. The rightful king is pushed to the margins; the Philistines, Israel's long-standing enemy, sit in his home town. One writer draws out how personally David felt this.

He lay in the stronghold. The armies of the Philistines were camped in Bethlehem, the place where he was born and brought up, every bit of it known and loved by him. As he lay in the stronghold, tired and thirsty, these three devoted men heard David say, "Oh, that someone would give me water to drink from the well of Bethlehem that is by the gate!"

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Bethlehem in enemy hands

Enemy soldiers held David's home town while he lived as an exile, and the king on the throne did nothing about it.

The garrison of the Philistines had taken possession of Bethlehem while David was in exile in the cave of Adullam. Saul did not have the energy to drive the Philistines out of Bethlehem, the house of bread. And David expressed a longing for a drink of water from the well of Bethlehem.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

That name carries weight far beyond David's day.

Bethlehem, meaning "house of bread," is a very fitting name for the place from which the Saviour should come as a man — He who was the living bread that came down from heaven.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Two men, two centres

While David hid in the stronghold, another king sat in a palace. Everyone in Israel had to choose between them.

The choice lay between Saul and David — Saul a picture of the man of the flesh, and David a type of Christ. Saul is in the palace. He sits on the throne. The kingdom is at his feet. David is in the cave of Adullam with a band of men gathered round him, drawn by affection, and devoted to his cause.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

The timing of their arrival says as much as the fact of it.

These three mighty men "came to David in the harvest time to the cave of Adullam." It seems as if they left the world in the day of its plenty. They chose to identify themselves with David in the day of his poverty and disgrace.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

A wish, not an order

David gave no order. He only said out loud what he wanted.

David was in the stronghold, while a garrison of the Philistines occupied the place of David's early home. David thinks of the well by the gate of Bethlehem. He had no doubt often drawn water there in his youth. Now he expresses his longing for a refreshing drink from that well… It is not a command that needs obedience. It is not a call to service. It is only the expression of his longing desire. And yet this expressed desire calls out this devoted act of love in a way that no command would have done.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Duty could have argued its way out of it.

No command was spoken, duty was not appealed to. A need expressed like that could never have found its way to the cold heart of duty. And if it had, there were plenty of reasons ready to keep it quiet. The Philistines had a garrison in Bethlehem and the well was inside the guarded gate, and the way there was very risky. David's thirst could not be quenched without great danger — and why quench it? It would please him, but it would not advance his people or his kingdom. … "David has not told us to attack Bethlehem. It is only his personal need, so why should we risk our lives to meet it?" Is that not the language of duty? But is it the language of love? … Does our Lord have no need now? Is He not thirsting now for what can only be gained by the self-sacrifice of His people?

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Service that benefits nobody but the King

Earlier exploits in this chapter won battles and protected people.

If the victories we have considered had the blessing of the people in view, this touching act of service was entirely for the benefit of the King.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

What it cost, and what it earned

What David did with the water mattered as much as the risk the men took to get it.

David's heart was deeply moved by this simple act. The men had won that water at the risk of their lives. So he poured it out to the Lord as a drink offering, because it showed how devoted these dear men were. It was the motive behind the action that turned that simple act into one which placed those three men at the very top of the roll of honour of the kingdom. That was when the fighting was all done, when power was established, and the day of rewards had come.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- Rejection. The rightful king sits in a stronghold while enemies hold his birthplace, and Saul on the throne does nothing.

- Attachment. Men left the world at harvest time to join David in his poverty. The choice between palace and cave still stands.

- Desire. David issued no order; he only voiced a longing, and that longing drew out love that a command never could have.

- Love above duty. Duty asks whether the risk advances the kingdom; love asks only what pleases the King. The water served no strategy at all.

- Reward. A small errand placed those three men at the top of the honour roll on the day David gave out rewards.

1 Chronicles 11:17 · Darby

And David longed, and said, Oh that one would give me to drink of the water of the well of Bethlehem, which is in the gate!

David is shut up in a stronghold, thirsty, and the Philistines hold Bethlehem, the town where he grew up. He sighs out loud for water from one well there — and that sigh, not an order, became a high point in the record of his warriors.

Warriors Who Loved David Himself

The chapter has just listed deeds of raw courage. This one is different: it shows what those men felt, not what they could do.

Then follow the true worthies of David, the true warriors, not for what was to be got, but for David. To the end of the chapter we see in detail not only their great deeds in cutting down the enemy, but their intense love for David... He knew his native place, and longed after the water that he had, no doubt, often drunk. He said this without a thought of anything further.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Why a Wish Moves More Than an Order

David named nobody and sent nobody. That silence is the point.

There was no command issued. No one in particular was singled out and commissioned to go. There was the simple expression of the desire, and this is what gave the opportunity for genuine affection and true devotedness. A specific command to someone would only have given an occasion for ready obedience. But the expression of a desire brought out that warm attachment to the person of David which is so lovely to see.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

One writer sets commands given to servants beside words spoken to friends.

This expressed wish of David never was a command, and was never meant to be. If we are to reach any worthy thoughts about it, we must distinguish between two things: the commands that are laid upon us — and there are such — and His "word," which shows us what is in His heart. In receiving that word we come into intelligent communion with Himself. The Lord Himself makes this distinction in His last words with His disciples (John 14:21, 23). Commands may be given to servants only, who are never let into the secrets of the heart. But words spoken to friends also claim a response, and will find one from the truly devoted. Not "what must I do?" but "what may I do?" is the language of attachment to His Person. Only so can we be in sympathy with the act of the mighty three.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Service That Benefits No One but the King

Set this errand beside the victories recorded just before it, and the difference is in who gains by it.

Whether in David's day or in our own, one thing marks such mighty deeds: they are for the benefit of people as well as for the glory of the King. But when we come to the three mighty men who drew the water from the well, we have a very different form of service. If the victories we have considered had the blessing of the people in view, this touching act of service was wholly for the benefit of the King.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The Thirst of the Greater David

Commentators read David here as a picture of Christ, and his craving as a shadow of a deeper one. Bethlehem's name means "house of bread."

Our David has cravings and longings of heart which also need the water of the well of Bethlehem for their satisfaction. They are not passing desires. As His nature is, they are lasting, perfect, necessary to His perfection. Is it not living water that He longs to receive from us, water whose spring is at the outgoing of the Father's "house of bread"? In it He finds only the fruit of the travail of His soul, and with it alone He can be satisfied.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

One writer hears the same note in what the Lord asked as His death drew near:

Is not David's "Oh, that one would give me" a faint anticipation of the Lord's dying request, "Do this in remembrance of Me"?

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Close Enough to Overhear

The three could answer a wish only because they lived close enough to hear it.

The three chiefs mentioned in 2 Sam. 23:13-17 must have been near enough to David to know the desires of his heart. His words were not a commandment, but the expression of his heart's desire. Do we live near enough to the Lord to know the desires of His heart?... Sometimes we find people of God saying, It does not say we are not to do this or that. They try to satisfy their natural desires on the plea that God has not forbidden the thing they want. Should we not seek to carry out not only the commandments of the Lord, but also the desires of His heart?

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

Summary

- Overheard. David names no one and orders nothing. The three act because they were near enough to hear him.

- Desire. A command would have produced obedience. A wish produced love.

- Friends. Servants get orders and stay outside the secrets of the heart. Friends get words — and ask not "what must I do?" but "what may I do?"

- For Him alone. Other exploits helped the people and honoured the King. This one profited nobody but Him — service aimed wholly at His heart.

- Echo. One writer hears in "Oh, that one would give me" the first faint note of "Do this in remembrance of Me" — a longing still waiting on willing hearts.

1 Chronicles 11:18 · Darby

And the three broke through the camp of the Philistines, and drew water out of the well of Bethlehem, which is in the gate, and took it, and brought it to David; David however would not drink of it, but poured it out to Jehovah.

David hides in a stronghold, enemy troops hold Bethlehem, his home town, and he sighs aloud for a drink from its well. Three of his men cut through the Philistine army to fetch it, and then the king pours it out on the ground instead of drinking it.

A Wish, Not an Order

No one ordered these men to go. One writer weighs what that absence produced:

David gave no command. He picked out no one and sent no one. He simply said what he wanted, and that is what made room for real affection and true devotion. A command to a named man would only have given him the chance to obey. But a spoken wish drew out that warm attachment to David himself, which is so lovely to see.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The Water Itself Was Ordinary

One writer tests the errand by common sense:

Common sense would have said that water from some other place would have satisfied David's thirst just as well. And that would have been true. Water is water wherever it is, and there was nothing special about the water of the well of Bethlehem.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

What moved them was the man who wanted it:

The Philistine army lay camped in tight ranks between the stronghold and the well. These three devoted men did not count the cost of the simple act of pleasing David. They wanted to please him. Nothing pleased them so much as pleasing him. Devotion put strength into their arms that day as they broke through the startled ranks of the Philistines and got the water for David.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Service for the King, Not for the Kingdom

One writer sets this errand beside the battles earlier in the chapter:

When we come to the three mighty men who drew the water from the well, we have a very different kind of service. If the victories we have looked at had the blessing of the people in view, this touching act of service was wholly for the benefit of the King.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Love Rather Than Warfare

The deed belongs to no military plan, and that is exactly why it stands out among the recorded acts of David's men.

It was no plan of war. It lay right outside the expedition. It was love. But David's act was more beautiful still. There are others too — not among the three mightiest, yet men who were most honourable. God loves to mention what is an honour to His people, and so after each of their names we find a record of their deeds. The Lord will do this and more for those who at any time have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Too Costly for the King to Drink

David will not drink. One writer explains why:

It was a sacrifice too costly for anyone except the LORD Himself. So David would not let anything interrupt its sweet smell as it rose to the throne of God.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Another writer finds two things in the refusal, and then a contrast with Christ:

His godly act showed two things. He judged the water too valuable for himself, and fit for the Lord alone. It also showed that the fear of the Lord was always before him. But One greater than David — the Son of God, David's Son according to the flesh — does drink the springing water that is brought to Him now, before He takes the throne of His glorious kingdom and dominion.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The Drink Offering and the Reward

One writer looks at what David did with the water, and where the deed placed these men later:

David poured out the water, won at the risk of their lives, to the Lord as a drink offering. It showed the devotion of these dear men. It was the motive behind the action that turned that simple deed into one which placed those three men at the very top of the glory roll of the kingdom — when the fighting was over, the kingdom was secure, and the day of rewards had come.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Giving Something Back to Christ

One writer brings David's wish into the present:

We, too, may fight the Lord's battles, but how much do we know of this higher service that does something for the heart of Christ alone? "Oh, that one would give me," says David. Are there not times when we can give something to the One who gave everything for us?… Do we count it a rare privilege to give Christ something that brings joy to His heart?

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Summary

- Desire — David gave no command; a longing spoken aloud drew out love that an order never could.

- Devotedness — the water had no special virtue, so the whole worth of the act lay in who wanted it.

- Difference — other feats in the chapter served the kingdom; this one served the King alone.

- Drink offering — David judged the gift too costly for himself and poured it out to God alone.

- Distinction — an act of love that no one ordered and no battle needed put three men at the top of the roll of honour on the day of rewards.

1 Chronicles 11:19 · Darby

And he said, My God forbid it me, that I should do this thing! should I drink the blood of these men [who went] at the risk of their lives? for at the risk of their lives they brought it. Therefore he would not drink it. These things did the three mighty men.

Three men broke through a Philistine army to fetch water from Bethlehem's well for David. He would not drink it, but poured it on the ground and called it blood — so why was a cup of water too holy to drink?

Water too costly to drink

David's refusal is an act of reverence, not waste:

It was a sacrifice too costly for anyone except the Lord Himself. So David would not allow the sweet scent of it to be interrupted on its way up to the throne of God.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

One writer follows the cup from their hands, through David's, to God:

The king valued their devotion, but he did not want to take advantage of it: "Shall I drink the lifeblood of these men?" He draws out the devotion of his men, and his own character is to give himself up for them. The water offered to him only passes through his hands, to be presented as a drink offering to the Lord. Everything done for Christ is done for God. God accepts it as an excellent sacrifice, offered up by Christ.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

A wish, not an order

No one ordered these men to go. One writer says that absence is the whole point:

No command was issued. No one in particular was picked out and sent. There was simply the expression of a desire. This is what gave the opportunity for genuine affection and true devotedness. A specific command to someone would only have given occasion for ready obedience. But the expression of a desire drew out that deep attachment to the person of David which is so lovely to see.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

For the King, not for the kingdom

One writer weighs this risk against service done for the kingdom's good:

Many would have been ready to risk their lives carrying out some service for the good of the kingdom. But these mighty men were ready to face death for something that served only David's desire.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Was the risk even necessary? One writer states the objection plainly:

Common sense would have said that water from some other place would have done just as well for David's thirst. That would have been perfectly true. Water is water wherever it is, and there was nothing special about the water of the well of Bethlehem.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

What made the water precious was that David had named that well.

Love that kept no record of itself

This account never names the three. One writer sees that silence as fitting:

It is no longer a matter of energy and endurance here, but of the devotion of faith. And this devotion flows naturally from the hearts of servants who know and appreciate their Master. By its very nature devotion is something hidden. What man has the right to boast of devotion?

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Their motive is what preserved the deed:

How little those three mighty men imagined that their act of loving devotion would be recorded forever in Scripture, to be read by millions. They never thought of this. If they had acted to get a name or a place for themselves, it would have stripped their act of all its beauty. It would then have deserved to be despised and forgotten. But no — they loved David. This was the spring of their activity. They proved that he was more precious to their hearts than life itself.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

God keeps the record

The verse ends by crediting the deed to the three mighty men. One writer sees a pattern in how Scripture records honour:

God loves to mention what is an honour to His people, and so after each of their names we find a record of their deeds. The Lord will do this and more for those who now and always have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Something given back to Him

One writer turns the scene into a question for the reader:

We too may fight the Lord's battles. But how much do we know of this higher service that does something for the heart of Christ alone? "Oh, that one would give me," says David. Are there not times when we can give something to the One who gave everything for us?

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Summary

- Desire. No order was given; a longing was overheard. A wish drew out love where a command would only have produced obedience.

- Danger. The water had no special virtue. What made it worth a Philistine army was that the one they loved had named that well.

- Devotion. They risked death for no gain to the kingdom. It was service aimed at one person: their king's refreshment.

- Drink offering. David judged the cup too costly for himself. He poured it out to the Lord, treating their love as a sacrifice fit only for God.

- Record. God wrote their hidden act into Scripture. Commentators take it as a pledge: He will do the same and more for all who live and suffer for His name.

1 Chronicles 11:20 · Darby

And Abishai the brother of Joab, he was the chief of three; and he brandished his spear against three hundred and slew them; and he had a name among the three.

One line holds Abishai's whole career: a spear, three hundred enemies, and a name. Why did God record this deed? And why does the same sentence that honours him also mark the limit of his honour?

A Name on God's Record

The list of David's warriors is a register kept by God, and its ranks are exact. One writer points to two other lists of names and deeds in the Bible, and to the fixed ranks inside David's own list:

Scripture gives us specimen pages from the book of eternity, where the finger of God has engraved the names of His servants and the record of their work. Turn to the twenty-third chapter of 2 Samuel, and to the sixteenth of Romans, and you will find two such pages: the names and deeds of David's warriors, and the names and deeds of Paul's friends at Rome. Both show what we are sure is true of all the saints of God and the servants of Christ, from first to last. Each one has his own special place on the roll, and each one his place in the Master's heart. It will all come out by and by. Among David's mighty men, we have "the first three," "the three" and "the thirty." Not one of "the thirty" ever reached a place among "the three." Nor did one of "the three" ever reach to "the first three."

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

One Man Against Three Hundred

Of everything Abishai did, one act stands for him in this list. Two things make it remarkable: the odds, and the finish:

He faced no less than three hundred of David's enemies alone! And he did not stop until he had killed them all! He went through hardship and trial with David during the time of David's rejection. We may be sure he learned much, and that he enjoyed a near place to the king in his glory. David might well say to him what another will say to His mighty men by and by: "Well done, good and faithful servant!"

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Honoured, Yet Short of the First Three

The verse gives him a name "beside the three" — near them, not among them. One writer sets him beside Joseb-Bassebeth, one of the first three, and names what he lacked:

The deeds of valour of these three men did not reach those of the first three. First there is Abishai. Like Joseb-Bassebeth, he brandished his spear against three hundred men and killed them. But he did not have the same perseverance of faith.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Family Ties Earn Nothing

Abishai had every natural advantage. He was close kin to the king and brother of the army's commander. None of it counted toward his place, and that cuts both ways for us:

After the first three, we have Abishai. He might have claimed a place of special distinction because of his natural relationships. He was brother to Joab, the captain of the army, and closely related to the king. But natural relationships do not secure a place in the kingdom for him, or for us. Abishai secures his distinguished place by his own strength. His great feat did not reach the height of the Tachmonite's, yet he was still marked by the same spirit of power. We cannot attain to the faithfulness and spiritual power that marked the Apostle Paul and other great servants of the Lord. But by the same divine grace we can be marked by the same spirit in our own measure. (Another mighty deed of Abishai's is found in 2 Samuel 21:16-17. He came to David's help when one of the giants tried to kill him, and he killed the giant.)

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

Kept by the King's Word

The verse names Abishai as Joab's brother and chief of a rank of warriors. (The ESV reads "chief of the thirty"; older translations read "chief of the three", the second group of three.) One writer says the likeness to Joab ran deeper than the family line:

Abishai is called "the brother of Joab" because he was like him in many ways, showing similar traits. But if he shared his brother's graceless hardness of heart, he was still ready to obey David's word. That kept him from most of Joab's mistakes. So, although he "did not attain to the first three", we find honour and distinction given to him without reserve. He was chief of the three — that is, the second three — and he was "more honourable" than the other two. This came of heeding the word of David and holding fast to him. When a servant of our Lord Jesus Christ heeds His word and keeps near to Him, much that is pleasing to God will be found in his service, even though there may be a great deal to try him.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Joab, by contrast, wins battle after battle and receives no line in the roll of honour at all:

Abishai, the brother of Joab, has a significant place as chief of these three men. Joab himself receives no honour at all in this final summing up of David's mighty men. He was a capable warrior who gained many victories, but his one fatal flaw was that his motives proved selfish. It was not God's honour that he sought, but his own.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Summary

- Name recorded. Each servant has his own place on a roll kept by God Himself, and it will all come out at last.

- Name earned. His honour came from his own deed against three hundred, not from his family ties to the king and the commander.

- Name limited. He won a name beside the three, never among them. The gap was perseverance of faith, not the deed.

- Name kept. He shared Joab's hard temper, but he obeyed David's word, and that kept him from most of Joab's mistakes.

- Name lost. Joab won more battles and received no honour at all, because he sought his own glory, not God's.

1 Chronicles 11:21 · Darby

Of the three he was more honourable than the two, and he was their captain; but he did not attain to the [first] three.

Abishai stands near the top of the list of David's warriors. He was honoured above his companions, yet he never reached the highest rank. Two questions follow: what earned him that honour, and why does Scripture record its limit?

The writers below quote older translations, which read "of the three he was more honourable than the two... he attained not to the first three." Their "three" is the second group of three.

A roll taken at the kingdom's beginning

One writer points out that the placing of this list changes what it means:

David's mighty men are listed at the beginning of this account (vv. 10-47), while 2 Samuel 23 lists them at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom... 2 Samuel lists them as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our present chapter they have only to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed.

Modernised from Henri L. RossierOriginal wording

Honour that cannot be inherited

Abishai had every natural advantage. He was Joab's brother and a relative of the king. None of that won him his place.

After the first three, we have Abishai. He might have claimed a place of special distinction because of his family ties. He was brother to Joab, the captain of the army, and a close relative of the king. But family ties do not secure a place in the kingdom for him, or for us. Abishai secures his distinguished place by his own prowess. His great feat did not reach the height of the Tachmonite's, yet the same spirit of power marked him. We cannot attain to the faithfulness and spiritual power that marked the Apostle Paul and other great servants of the Lord. But the same spirit can mark us in our own measure, by the same divine grace.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

Why he was honoured, and why he stopped short

One writer traces both Abishai's likeness to Joab and his difference from him:

Abishai is called "the brother of Joab", for he was like him in many ways and showed similar traits. Even if he shared his brother's graceless hardness of heart, he was still ready to obey David's word, and that kept him from most of Joab's mistakes. So although he "attained not to the first three", we find honour and distinction given to him without reserve. "He was chief of the three" (that is, the second three), we are told, and he was "more honourable" than the other two. This was the result of heeding the word of David while staying close to him.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Another writer compares Abishai with one of the first three, who did a similar feat with a spear:

These three men's deeds of valour did not reach those of the first three. First there is Abishai. Like Joseb-Bassebeth, he brandished his spear against three hundred men and killed them. But he did not have the same perseverance of faith.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Ranks that are real and fixed

These ranks are fixed. No one crosses from one into the next:

Each one has his own special place on the roll, and each one his place in the Master's heart; and all will come out by and by. Among David's mighty men, we have "the first three", "the three" and "the thirty". Not one of "the thirty" ever attained a place among "the three". Nor did one of "the three" ever reach to "the first three".

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Yet the limit is no slight. God keeps this record to honour His servants:

There are others, however — not, it is true, among the three mightiest, but who were most honourable. God loves to mention what is an honour to His people; and so, after each of their names we find a record of their deeds. The Lord will do this and more for those who now and always have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The day of rewards

One writer brings this down to our own day:

Our Lord is now rejected, but "The crowning day is coming by and by." Now is the time to show which side we are on. Now is the time to prize the cross as great reward. Devotedness is not seen in waiting for tasks that will bring us into publicity, into work that is spectacular. It is seen in a readiness to do the humblest, most menial work that needs doing in the service of the Lord.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- Honour earned. Abishai's kinship to Joab and to the king gave him nothing; his place came from his own deeds.

- Honour kept. What preserved him from his brother's ruin was obeying David's word and staying near him.

- Honour measured. He was more honoured than his two companions, but never reached the first three. The gap was perseverance, not courage.

- Honour fixed. The three ranks never blend; no one of the thirty rose to the three, and none of the three to the first three.

- Honour recorded. God loves to name what honours His people. He will do this and more for those who serve Christ while He is rejected.

1 Chronicles 11:22 · Darby

Benaiah the son of Jehoiada, the son of a valiant man, great in exploits, of Kabzeel he it was that smote two lions of Moab; and he went down and smote a lion in the midst of a pit on a snowy day.

Benaiah served David, and this verse gives his record in one line: two Moabite fighters killed, and a lion killed in a pit on a snowy day. Commentators ask what his names mean, why the snow is mentioned, and what a lion in a pit has to do with us.

Names That Tell a Story

The verse gives three names before it tells us anything he did: the man, his father, and his hometown. One writer takes them together as a description of the man God had made.

Benaiah means "Whom God has built"; Jehoiada, "Jehovah knows"; and Kabzeel, "God has gathered." Put these meanings together, and we learn this. Benaiah was the son of one whom the Lord knew ("I know my sheep"). God Himself had built him up in the truth. And he knew his place in God's assembly (Kabzeel).

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Older translations call the two Moabites he struck down "lion-like men." The Hebrew behind that phrase says more still.

In 2 Sam. 23:20; 1 Chr. 11:22, we read that Benaiah killed two "lion-like men," which some prefer to translate "two sons of Ariel." The Hebrew is literally "two lions of God."

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Three Enemies

Benaiah's record has three parts: the men of Moab, the lion, and the Egyptian of the next verse.

He is specially singled out for his victories over (1) two men of Moab; (2) a lion; and (3) an Egyptian. How these three remind us of (1) the flesh; (2) Satan; and (3) the world. In the service of our Lord Jesus Christ, it is a great day when we accept the condemnation of the cross upon sin in the flesh. From then on we walk and war after the Spirit.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The Pit and the Snow

Benaiah went down into the lion's den at the worst time of year. One writer sees a picture of Christ in that descent.

He went down into a pit to slay a lion; surely a lovely picture of the One who went down into the lower parts of the earth, having gone down into death... When Benaiah went down into the pit it was "the time of snow," everything was in the grip of winter, there was not a trace of life to be seen. It was the same with the blessed Lord Jesus. He went down into death to destroy him who had the power of death, and there was not a breath for God in the whole universe... Benaiah came up out of the pit victorious, having killed the lion. In the same way the blessed Lord rose out of death. He had burst its iron gates and destroyed its power forever.

Modernised from Scripture QuarterlyOriginal wording

Another writer sets that snowy day beside the day Adam fell.

It was on a snowy day this happened; the circumstances of the conflict were all against Benaiah; yet he was victorious. When Adam fell, the circumstances of Eden were all in his favour. But Christ met the foe in the temptations, in Gethsemane, and at the cross. How very different His circumstances were from those of the first man when he fell before the enemy!

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

What It Asks of Us

Benaiah did not wait for better weather, and he fought on the enemy's ground. Commentators find the same pattern in a believer's fights today.

On a snowy day he did not hesitate to go down into a pit and kill a lion. The faithful are like him now. Sometimes they have to enter the closest conflict with Satan under the most distressing circumstances, and they overcome him by the sword of the Spirit. He also killed an Egyptian with the Egyptian's own spear. We may sometimes see the same thing now. A worldly man opposes the servants and the truth of God, and the very weapon he used against them defeats him. So God turns the wrath of man to praise Him.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

The Reward of a Follower

Benaiah fought the way David fought. One writer traces where that likeness led him.

Benaiah walks faithfully in his master's steps, and his great affection for David leads him to reproduce his model's traits. Such a walk finds its reward: "David set him in his council" (v. 23), a place of confidence, intimacy, and communion. Benaiah shares his master's secrets, learns his plans from him, and sees the king's face at all times. What a blessed portion!

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Summary

- Built — his name means "whom God has built," his father's "Jehovah knows," his town "God has gathered." The deeds came out of a man God had already made.

- Three — Moab, lion and Egyptian stand for the flesh, Satan and the world; even the enemy's own spear becomes the weapon that defeats him.

- Down — he went down into the pit, the enemy's own ground, and killed the lion there. Christ went down further, into death itself, and rose.

- Snow — the day was against him and he still won. Adam fell in Eden's easy conditions; Christ won in the hardest.

- Council — he copied his master's victories, and David gave him a place close to the king, with a share in his secrets.

1 Chronicles 11:23 · Darby

He also smote the Egyptian, a man of stature, five cubits high and in the Egyptian's hand was a spear like a weaver's beam; and he went down to him with a staff, and plucked the spear out of the Egyptian's hand, and slew him with his own spear.

The list of David's mighty men saves its longest entry for Benaiah, and his last fight looks hopeless: a staff against a spear like a weaver's beam. Why does God record this one duel in such detail, and what can a staff do against a spear?

A staff against a spear

The match was uneven. One writer reads it in the light of the cross.

The Egyptian was a huge man, and he carried a spear like a weaver's beam. Yet Benaiah defeated him with only a staff in his hand. He pulled the spear from him, turned it against its owner, and killed him. It is through the cross of Christ that we get the victory over the world by faith in the Son of God who makes known the Father's love to us. The world lifted up its hand against Christ. Yet the death He died defeated the world for faith. So one could write, "far be it from me to boast except in the cross of our Lord Jesus Christ, by which the world has been crucified to me, and I to the world."

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The spear as a picture of death

One writer lines this fight up with David and Goliath, and finds meaning in the weapon itself.

David beheaded Goliath with Goliath's own sword. In the same way Benaiah "snatched the spear out of the Egyptian's hand and killed him with his own spear." The spear, like the sword, is a symbol of the power of death. As another writer has said, "Death is the best weapon in the arsenal of God when it is used by the power of life." This was Benaiah's experience in his fight with the world — the Egyptian. Take the whole history, and we learn that this child of grace… meets and overcomes the flesh, Satan, and the world. This too was of grace; but, while it was of grace, it shows the path and the possibility open to every believer.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Why the enemy is an Egyptian

Egypt is not a random nationality here. One writer reads it as a picture of the world, and puts Benaiah's win beside Christ's own.

Do we not see the glory of the world, and its bondage for the people of God in Egypt? But we read of One who said, "I have overcome the world" (John 16:33)… Benaiah kills the Egyptian with his own spear. In the same way we read of the Lord's great triumph in Hebrews: "that through death he might destroy the one who has the power of death" (Heb. 2:14). If the Lord has overcome the world, He can enable us to overcome it also.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

A soldier shaped by his king

Benaiah did not invent his tactics. One writer traces the likeness back to love for David, and follows it through to its reward.

He killed the Egyptian just as David had struck down Goliath. David had taken the giant's sword to cut off his head, and Benaiah put the Egyptian to death with his own spear. Benaiah walks in his master's steps, and his great love for David leads him to reproduce his model's traits. Such a walk finds its reward: a place of confidence, intimacy, and communion. Benaiah shares his master's secrets and sees the king's face at all times. If we love the Lord Jesus, and follow and serve Him, we will be rewarded with a nearness like that of John, the disciple Jesus loved, whose place was closest to Him.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The same fight today

The pattern did not stay in the past. One writer sees the same reversal when people oppose the truth today.

He also killed an Egyptian with his own spear. The same thing can sometimes be seen now. A worldly man opposes the servants and the truth of God, and the very weapon he used against them defeats him. So God turns the wrath of man to praise Him.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Summary

- Staff. Benaiah went down to a giant with only a staff in his hand. He did not win by matching weapons, and writers point to the cross as the ground of that victory.

- Spear. The spear he pulled from the Egyptian's hand stands for the power of death. When the power of life uses it, death becomes God's best weapon.

- World. The Egyptian pictures the glory of the world, and Egypt pictures its hold on God's people. The One who has overcome the world can make His own overcome it too.

- Master. Benaiah fought the way David fought. Love for his king had reproduced his king's traits in him.

- Reward. That walk ends in nearness to the king, a place of confidence and communion. And the old reversal still happens: the weapon raised against the truth turns on the one who raised it.

1 Chronicles 11:24 · Darby

These things did Benaiah the son of Jehoiada, and he had a name among the three mighty men.

This verse closes the account of Benaiah, one of David's warriors: his deeds won him a name beside the three mighty men. Two questions follow. What wins a name like that? And who keeps the record?

The Man Behind the Deeds

One writer gives Benaiah's family background, from the priestly line of Aaron, then the test he passed when Joab did not:

Jehoiada, Benaiah's father, was leader of the Aaronites (1 Chron. 12:27). The family came from Kabzeel, one of the furthest cities of the tribe of Judah, toward the border of Edom to the south (Joshua 15:21). In 1 Chron. 27:5 the record calls him "a chief priest". Solomon's rise to the throne brought strife and jealousy. Even Joab turned aside after Adonijah. Through it all, Benaiah was always true and loyal.

Modernised from George C WillisOriginal wording

What "These Things" Were

The deeds summed up here are the three victories just before this verse: two men of Moab, a lion in a pit, and an Egyptian. One writer reads the three enemies as pictures of what every believer fights:

The record singles him out for his victories over (1) two men of Moab; (2) a lion; and (3) an Egyptian. How these three remind us of (1) the flesh; (2) Satan; and (3) the world. It is a great day when, in the service of our Lord Jesus Christ, we accept the condemnation of the cross upon sin in the flesh. From then on we walk and war after the Spirit.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

What the Names Point To

Both names in this verse carry meaning, and so does the hometown named earlier. One writer reads them together, with a warning first:

Interpreting the meaning of Scripture names needs great caution. Even so, they often hold very instructive lessons. In this passage the combination of the different names is very remarkable. Benaiah means "Whom God has built"; Jehoiada, "Jehovah knows"; and Kabzeel, "God has gathered." Put these meanings together, and we learn much. Benaiah was the son of one whom the Lord knew ("I know my sheep"). God Himself had built him up in the truth. And he knew his place in God's assembly (Kabzeel). … Taking the whole history, we learn that this child of grace, built up on his most holy faith, and gathered out onto the ground of God's assembly, meets and overcomes the flesh, Satan, and the world. This too was of grace; but, while of grace, it reveals the path and possibility for every believer.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Why the Record Exists at All

Benaiah's name stands beside the three mightiest, not inside their number. One writer shows the honour that remains, and why each man's deeds are listed:

There are others however — not, it is true, among the three mightiest, but who were most honourable. God loves to mention what is an honour to His people; and so, after each of their names, we find a record of their deeds. The Lord will do this and more for those who now and always have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Near the King in Both Seasons

Benaiah's loyalty did not rise and fall with David's fortunes:

Benaiah was with David when many were against him. He was also with him when the crowds owned him king and bowed before him. His fellowship with the anointed of God seems to have been unbroken. It held in hardship and in prosperity, in the cave and on the throne, in the wars with countless enemies and in the government of God's people. No wonder David set him over his guard. He would be glad to have such a man close to himself.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The Day the Names Are Read Out

Benaiah's deeds happened with no crowd watching. We know them only because the Spirit of God recorded them. One writer links that record to a coming day:

When David was at rest in his kingdom, their names and deeds stood on record, remembered faithfully. None were forgotten. That record surely leads the reader's mind on to the time when the Lord Christ will reward His faithful servants. They are the ones who, out of love to His person and by the energy of His Spirit, have done acts of service for Him in the time of His rejection. Men may never see, know, or even think of these acts. But Jesus knows them, and He will declare them openly from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known the acts of David's worthies if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Built. His name means "whom God has built" — the strength shown in the verse traces back to what God had made him, not to raw nerve.

- Battles. The three deeds are read as victories over the flesh, Satan, and the world — a path open to every believer, and all of grace.

- Bond. He was with David in the cave and on the throne alike; the constancy, not a single exploit, is what stands out.

- Name. His name stands beside the three mightiest, and the record keeps his deeds. God loves to mention what is an honour to His people.

- Reward. What no one saw, Jesus knows — and will declare publicly from the throne of His glory.

1 Chronicles 11:25 · Darby

Behold, he was honoured above the thirty, but he did not attain to the [first] three. And David set him in his council.

Benaiah's record ends with a double verdict: renowned among the thirty, yet never one of the three. So why did David hand the man passed over for the top rank the post closest to himself?

The List That Brings In the Kingdom

This list of David's warriors stands at the front of his reign, not at its close.

David's mighty men come at the beginning of this account (vv. 10-47), while 2 Samuel 23 puts them at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom. They "gave him strong support in his kingdom, together with all Israel, to make him king, according to the word of the LORD concerning Israel" (v. 10). So they carried out the plans which God had already made known.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

A Man Who Copied His Master

Benaiah's exploits trace the pattern of David's own life. The comment below reads "in his council," following an older translation; the ESV has "over his bodyguard."

He fought the enemies from outside, Moab and Egypt, and killed two Moabite heroes. Like David he fought a lion all by himself. He killed the Egyptian just as David had struck down Goliath. David used the giant's own sword to cut off his head; in the same way Benaiah killed the Egyptian with the man's own spear. Benaiah walks faithfully in his master's steps, and his great affection for David leads him to reproduce his model's traits. Such a walk finds its reward: "David set him in his council," a place of confidence, intimacy, and communion. Benaiah shares his master's secrets, knows his plans, and sees the king's face at all times. What a blessed portion! If we love the Lord Jesus, follow Him obediently and serve Him, our reward will be a nearness like John's. He was the beloved disciple, whose place was close to the heart of Jesus.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Honour He Never Chased

Set Benaiah beside Joab, and their motives run in opposite directions.

In David's time Benaiah already held a leading place in service (1 Chr. 27:5). He had followed the footprints of his master step by step in everything, and later became chief captain over the entire army. Was he not worthy of it? Yet this man has no ambition other than to remain faithful to his king and to imitate him. He is not like Joab who takes the stronghold of Zion to gain the first place. No, he is humble, for his whole purpose is to reproduce David in his conduct.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Why the Guard

Benaiah's loyalty to David never changed with David's fortunes.

Benaiah was with David when many were against him, and he was with him when the crowds owned him king and bowed before him. His communion with the anointed of God seems to have been unbroken. It held in trouble and in prosperity, in the cave and on the throne, in the wars with countless foes and in the government of God's people. No wonder David set him over his guard. He would be glad to have such a man close to himself.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The Grades Are Not Careless

This grading of servants is not unique to David's men.

Why does the inspired writer not place "Tryphaena, Tryphosa," and "the beloved Persis" under one head? Why not give them the same position? The reason is beautiful. Of the first two he could only say that they were "workers in the Lord," while of the last he had to add that she "worked hard in the Lord." Can anything be more discriminating? It is "the three" — "the first three" — and "the thirty" over again. There is no careless jumbling of names and services together; no haste; no inaccuracy. Each one gets his own place, and receives his own measure of praise.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

God's measure is not the one men use when they hand out rank.

Though one as servants, "each will receive his wages according to his labour". The reward will not be according to the position that man may have given the servant, nor according to man's thoughts of his service, but according to God's estimate of his labours.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

From the Guard Post to the Glory

Benaiah's life did not stop at the bodyguard.

"With David" in his rejection and fightings; "with David" as captain of his bodyguard; "with David" in his kingdom in positions of honour; he was now raised to be captain of the army of Israel with David's son Solomon, sharing in his glorious reign when wars were past. Tried and proved trustworthy, he richly reaped a blessed reward. In the glories of the coming day, those who follow our Lord Jesus Christ now will be "with the Lord" whom they have loved and served. How welcome that will be to their hearts!

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Summary

- Cause — imitation. Benaiah copied his master step by step, and that is what put him where this verse finds him.

- Gift — nearness. The reward for that walk was not rank but access: the guard post, the king's council, the king's face at all times.

- Guard — constancy. He was with David in the cave and on the throne, in war and in government, which is why David wanted him closest.

- Grade — exactness. "The three," "the first three," "the thirty" — God's record grades service exactly, and never by the rank men give.

- Result — the kingdom. Benaiah stood with Solomon when the fighting was over. Those who serve a rejected King now will be with Him in His glory.

1 Chronicles 11:26 · Darby

And the valiant men of the forces were Asahel the brother of Joab, Elhanan the son of Dodo of Bethlehem,

This verse opens the list of the thirty — the wider circle of David's fighting men — with Asahel and Elhanan. Why does God keep such a list, and what is a name worth when no deed comes with it?

Why the list stands where it does

One writer notes where this list stands in Chronicles, and what that shows about the men in it.

David's mighty men are listed at the beginning of this account (vv. 10-47), while in 2 Samuel 23 they come at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom. They "gave him strong support in his kingdom, together with all Israel, to make him king, according to the word of the LORD concerning Israel" (v. 10). So they carried out the plans God had already made known… Our chapter refers to 81 mighty men, and 30 of them are not named. 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. There they appear as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our present chapter they have only to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed. They cannot do anything but support a kingship that came out of the counsels of God Himself.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Ranks that no one can trade

Asahel does not stand among the top three. He heads a lower grade, and one writer finds in these ranks a picture of how God places and rewards each servant.

There were "the thirty," "the three," and "the first three." Each one gets his own specific place on the page of the book of responsible, practical life, according to what he was or what he had done. What is more, the record tells us exactly what each one did and how he did it. Nothing is forgotten. Everything is faithfully recorded, and no one can ever get another's place. Each does his own work, fills his own niche, and gets his own reward.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Asahel at the head — and the reason for it

David's three nephews head the three lists. One writer explains why that is not favouritism.

Asahel's name stands at the top of the list of the thirty captains. His career as a soldier was short, as we have seen. But we cannot help noticing that David's sister's sons head the three lists. Joab was chief and captain; Abishai the chief of the second three; and Asahel first of the thirty. This was not mere partiality. Rather it proves that the sense of a known relationship with the Anointed of God produces a good soldier.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The warning in Asahel's death

The same writer also reads a warning in the way Asahel's life ended.

Asahel's career was cut short through too much zeal, not balanced by the necessary grace and wisdom. What might have been a brilliant path of service ended suddenly, when the spear of one of God's own people killed him. That man was a distinguished soldier, and Asahel insisted on chasing him despite a warning given in time. It is not for the servants of Christ to seek the hurt of any of God's children. Learn a lesson from Asahel's sad mistake. David never chased Saul, though Saul often sought David's life.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Elhanan — which one?

A second Elhanan appears in Scripture, and the two are easy to confuse.

Elhanan. Son of Jair, or Jaare-oregim: he killed Lahmi the brother of Goliath the Gittite. 2 Sam. 21:19; 1 Chr. 20:5.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The Elhanan of this verse is the son of Dodo, and Scripture records no exploit of his. One writer shows why that silence still counts.

They were the men who loved David, stood by him, and showed their loyalty and devotion to the King. Others are listed too, and we read of no definite deeds from them… When He comes as the righteous Ruler, to bring in the morning without clouds, He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him while people rejected Him. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

A roll David could not edit

The same list that honours Asahel and Elhanan runs on to a name that accused the king himself.

Last we find the "thirty," less famous than the six men before them, though the Lord forgets none of His own… When David looked over the list of His servants, his eyes must have paused with sorrow at the name of Uriah the Hittite, which ends the list. Uriah was among the mighty men, and not the least of those hearts devoted to the king and his people. And David had had him put to death to satisfy his own lust! His name stayed there as a testimony against the one whom he had served. But David condemned himself and exalted the grace that had restored him. So he would never have dreamed of erasing that name from the book where it was recorded.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Summary

- Relationship — a known tie to God's anointed king is what makes a good soldier. David's three nephews head the three lists as proof of that, not as favouritism.

- Rank — the thirty, the three, the first three: each man has his own niche, his own reward, and no one can take another's place.

- Record — Elhanan has no exploit beside his name, yet his name stands. No name and no deed, however small, will be forgotten.

- Restraint — Asahel's zeal ran ahead of wisdom and cost him his career. He died chasing one of God's own people, not an enemy.

- Reign — in Chronicles this list opens David's reign instead of closing it. These men do not prop up a throne. They acknowledge a kingship God had already established.

1 Chronicles 11:27 · Darby

Shammoth the Harorite, Helez the Pelonite,

This verse gives two names and no deeds: Shammoth, from Harod, and Helez, known as the Pelonite. So why does God record such a list of David's mighty men at all?

Where the List Stands

This list of men appears twice in Scripture. The two versions sit in different places and count different numbers of men.

This account lists David's mighty men at the beginning (vv. 10-47), while 2 Samuel 23 lists them at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom… This chapter leaves out a few names that Samuel mentions, and adds a great many. So our chapter refers to 81 mighty men (it records 30 of them without naming them); 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. In Samuel they appear as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our chapter they only have to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed. They can do nothing other than support a kingship that came out of the counsels of God Himself.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The Two Names

In 2 Samuel 23, Helez carries a different title, and Shammoth may appear under a different name too. And no one knows why Helez is called the Pelonite.

Shammoth. A Harorite, one of David's mighty men. 1 Chr. 11:27. Perhaps the same as Shammah the Harodite in 2 Sam. 23:25.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Pelonite. Designation of Helez and Ahijah, two of David's mighty men. Why they are so called is not known. 1 Chr. 11:27, 36; 1 Chr. 27:10. In 2 Sam. 23:26 Helez is called "the Paltite."

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Little Known, Worth Digging

One writer admits that this kind of verse leaves him almost nothing to say. He treats the gap as a reason to dig.

We know the thirty (thirty-one) only by their names, and we can say little about them until they have been studied more closely… In lists like this one, dry and barren as our neglect has let them remain, we may expect to find many textual errors… Let the people of God study His word; dig deep, and expect much. Then we shall soon have few such complete gaps in our knowledge as we now have to regret here.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Why They Are Honoured

These men are on the list because of a choice. One man held the palace and the throne; the other held a cave.

The list of David's mighty men in 1 Chronicles 11 gives a wonderful illustration of devotedness. The choice lay between Saul and David — Saul an illustration of the carnal man and David a type of Christ. Saul is in the palace. He sits on the throne. The kingdom is at his feet. David is in the cave of Adullam. A band of men has gathered round him, drawn by affection and devoted to his cause.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Where the Strength Came From

Men like Shammoth and Helez were not born heroes. One writer traces their strength to God's power at work.

The man who has God with him attracts those in whom God is working. Their energy grows in step with the showing of His presence and favour. Many of these men had been with Saul. While they were with him they were not mighty men… These were only the chief of the mighty men David had. When God acts in power, He gives strength to the weak. By the energy of faith and of His Spirit He produces an army of heroes.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Nothing Forgotten

A name with no story is still a name God chose to write down. One writer applies that to service done for Christ today.

Because they were joined to David, his men were called to go through much toil and weariness. But love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and deeds were recorded and remembered without fail when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten… Men may never see, know, or think of these acts. But Jesus knows them, and He will declare them openly from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known the acts of David's worthies if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

A Near Place, One Pre-eminent Name

Closeness to David shaped these men, and it settled who came first in their hearts.

The thirty mighty men who were with David had a near place to him. No doubt they learned lessons from him, and those lessons secured the distinctions that became theirs. They owed all to David. They would rightly esteem Joab and the other captains, but David was pre-eminent in all their hearts and minds. He was God's anointed one. There must be no rival. All others are fellow-helpers in the war.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Summary

- Named by choice — Shammoth and Helez are on this roll because they chose the man in the cave over the man on the throne.

- Named by grace — their strength was not native to them; God gives strength to the weak and makes an army of heroes.

- Named in two lists — Chronicles puts the roll at the start, where these men bring in the kingdom. Its details differ from 2 Samuel 23.

- Named though unexplained — nobody knows why Helez is called the Pelonite. Such a gap invites us to dig, not to skip.

- Named for the day of glory — no act of service for Christ is lost; Jesus knows it and will declare it from His throne.

1 Chronicles 11:28 · Darby

Ira the son of Ikkesh the Tekoite, Abiezer the Anathothite,

Two more names pass by in the roll of David's warriors. Neither Ira of Tekoa nor Abiezer of Anathoth has a single battle story attached. Why does a book so taken up with kingship record men whose deeds it never tells?

The roll that brings in the kingdom

Chronicles places this list at the start of David's reign, not at the end.

David's mighty men are listed at the beginning of this account (vv. 10-47), while they are listed at the end in 2 Samuel 23. Here they bring in the kingdom. They "gave him strong support in his kingdom, together with all Israel, to make him king, according to the word of the LORD concerning Israel" (v. 10). So they carried out the plans which God had made known beforehand. So this chapter refers to 81 mighty men, 30 of them recorded without being named. 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. There they are listed as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. Here they only have to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed.

Modernised from Henri RossierOriginal wording

Where such men came from

These men did not come from Israel's nobility.

The Lord of hosts is marshalling the strength and power of Israel. And the Holy Spirit gives a list of tried men of might. They are set before us in the glow of their own bravery. The foremost of these worthies joined David while he was a fugitive and an outcast (1 Chron. 12:1-22); their origin is given (1 Sam. 22:2) and is one instance among many of God's taking up the despised of men and exalting them.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Two towns, two directions

Tekoa lay in Judah, and its people appear once more in Scripture — with a pointed comment attached.

Designation of Ikkesh, father of Ira, one of David's mighty men. 2 Sam. 23:26; 1 Chr. 11:28; 1 Chr. 27:9. The Tekoites were inhabitants of Tekoa: they helped to rebuild the wall of Jerusalem, but "their nobles did not put their necks to the work of their Lord." Neh. 3:5, 27.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Abiezer's town, Anathoth, lay in another tribe — the tribe with every natural reason to stay loyal to Saul.

Jeremiah the prophet belonged to the family of "the priests who were in Anathoth in the land of Benjamin." His village of Anathoth lay a little over three miles northeast of Jerusalem. It had been given to the priests, descendants of Aaron, of the family of the Kohathites (Josh. 21:18; 1 Chron. 6:60). Abiathar the priest was from Anathoth (1 Kings 2:26).

Modernised from Georges AndréOriginal wording

Coming from Benjamin was itself the test

Men of Benjamin who crossed over to David gave up something their neighbours kept.

The first men pointed out as having come to him were from among the brothers of Saul — that is, from the tribe of Benjamin. This is a proof that God and the knowledge of His will had more value in their eyes than parentage and the advantages which flow from it. They were men of the greatest skill in handling the bow and the sling, the weapons with which Saul was killed in the battle in which he was overthrown.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

A name kept when no deed is told

Ira and Abiezer have no exploit recorded.

Many other names are also ranked among David's worthies without any special mark of devotedness, or of victories being recorded.

Modernised from H. H. SnellOriginal wording

Another writer ties the keeping of such names to what the Lord will do for His own.

There are others however — not, it is true, among the three mightiest, but who were most honourable. God loves to mention what is an honour to His people. The Lord will do this and more for those who now and always have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The names that are absent

The list is as telling in what it leaves out.

Notice that the greatest warrior, the wisest counsellor, and one of the chief religious officials are all absent from the list of the king's worthies. We mean Joab, Ahithophel, and Abiathar.

Modernised from H. H. SnellOriginal wording

Abiathar came from Anathoth too, yet his name is missing. Snell draws the lesson from the contrast.

So we see that the unassuming, devoted, and afflicted Uriah the Hittite (v. 39), and many more, stayed true to David in the time of trial. But there were others who stood foremost in Israel for their strength, wisdom, or official religiousness. When the kingdom was set up in glory, they were judged and brought low instead of commended and exalted.

Modernised from H. H. SnellOriginal wording

Summary

- Rejected men. They joined David while he was a fugitive and an outcast. God takes up the despised of men and exalts them.

- A cost paid. Anathoth lay in Benjamin. Men who left Saul's own tribe for David valued God's will above parentage and the advantages it brings.

- A record kept. Chronicles puts the list at the start of the reign. These men bring in the kingdom, making David king according to God's word.

- Honour without deeds. Ira and Abiezer are ranked among the worthies with no victory recorded. God loves to mention what is an honour to His people.

- Names left out. Joab, Ahithophel, and Abiathar are missing — the strongest, the wisest, the most religious. They were brought low when the kingdom came in glory.

1 Chronicles 11:29 · Darby

Sibbechai the Hushathite, Ilai the Ahohite,

This line of the chapter carries two names and nothing more, buried in a long roll of David's fighting men. Why does God pause to name soldiers whose deeds He does not even tell here?

Why the List Exists

The chapter first tells of the three mighty men who broke through the Philistine camp to bring David water. Men like the two here come next. Their names, commentators say, are the point.

There are others, however — not among the three mightiest, but who were most honourable. God loves to mention what is an honour to His people; and so, after each of their names, we find a record of their deeds. The Lord will do this and more for those who now and ever have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Another writer ties their record to God's honouring of David himself, and notes one name that is missing.

If God honours and glorifies David, He does not forget the men whom the energy of David's faith had drawn around him. The Holy Spirit lists the mighty men of David and tells of their deeds of valour and devotion. Those deeds win them a name and a place when God writes up the people (Psalm 87). Joab is not among them.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Who These Two Men Were

The titles attached to these names point back to a family. One of them belongs to two of David's mighty men.

A title for Sibbechai and Mebunnai, two of David's mighty men, probably of the family of Hushah.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

In the matching list in 2 Samuel, the second man carries a different name.

The Ahohite, one of David's guard. He seems to be the same man as Zalmon in 2 Sam. 23:28.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Sibbecai's One Recorded Deed

Here Sibbecai is only a name. Elsewhere Scripture records one of his fights, and a writer draws from it a word for anyone battling an old enemy alone.

The Hushathite who killed Saph, or Sippai, a Philistine giant.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

It does not matter if our David is absent, as He was in the two battles at Gob; the same Spirit that urged Him on is still with us. Perhaps we may stand alone, as Sibbechai the Hushathite stood alone against Saph. The beaten giant always comes back in another form. What does that matter? Perhaps Gob, the place where he was defeated, will become a battlefield for us a second time — a discouraging situation. What does it matter if we must retrace the same steps when we thought we had finished with a treacherous struggle?

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Less Famous, Not Forgotten

Sibbecai and Ilai belong to the larger group that follows the celebrated few. Their lower rank changes nothing about God's memory of them, one writer says.

Last of all we find the "thirty." They are less famous than the six men before them, though the Lord forgets none of His own.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Rank on this list is real, but so is the permanence of each man's own place in it.

There were "the thirty," "the three," and "the first three." Each gets his own place on the page of the book of responsible, practical life. That place matches what he was or what he had done. We are told in detail what each one did and how he did it. Nothing is forgotten. All of it is recorded faithfully, and no one can ever get another's place. Each does his own work, fills his own niche, and gets his own reward.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Where Their Strength Came From

Where did such courage come from? One writer points back to the king himself.

Who had trained these men, who shortly before had abandoned their cities and hidden themselves in fear of the Philistines? God's chosen man was there, anointed to be king over Israel, and the kingdom was turned to him. This is the reason for their sudden gift of valour and might. It is the reason too for some of the wonderful deeds of the famous men whom the Holy Spirit names.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

The Pattern for Today

Commentators read this list forward, to Christ. Rejection comes first, and reigning after.

David was the anointed of God, and the throne of Israel was his. But it was during the time of his rejection that hardship and war tested and proved the sterling qualities of his mighty men. So it is today; our Lord Jesus Christ, the Anointed of God, is rejected by the world... We know that His final exaltation is certain. Like David, He will reign supreme. Then those who suffer with Him now will reign with Him.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Summary

- Recorded — This verse gives two names and no deeds. Yet God loves to name what honours His people, so nothing they did is lost.

- Identified — Sibbecai came from the family of Hushah and killed the Philistine giant Saph, also called Sippai. Ilai appears as Zalmon in the matching list in 2 Samuel.

- Alone — Sibbecai faced his giant by himself. One writer applies this to the old enemy who keeps coming back, and to the battlefield we must return to a second time.

- Ranked — Sibbecai and Ilai belong to "the thirty," not "the three." Rank differs, yet the Lord forgets none of His own. No one can take another man's place or reward.

- Rewarded — These men grew mighty because the anointed king had come to the throne. Their story runs forward: those who share the rejection of God's Anointed now will share His reign.

1 Chronicles 11:30 · Darby

Maharai the Netophathite, Heled the son of Baanah the Netophathite,

This verse gives two men, a father, and a village — and nothing else. So why does God record the name of a soldier whose deeds we never read?

The roll of a rejected king

These names come from a time when Israel had to choose between two men.

The list of David's mighty men in 1 Chronicles 11 gives a wonderful illustration of devotedness. The choice lay between Saul and David — Saul a picture of the man ruled by his sinful nature, and David a picture of Christ. Saul is in the palace. He sits on the throne. The kingdom is at his feet. David is in the cave of Adullam with a band of men gathered round him. Love drew them, and they are devoted to his cause.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Two men of one village

Both men came from the same village, Netophah. Maharai's name appears in three lists, not one.

Maharai. The Netophathite, one of David's mighty men. 2 Sam. 23:28; 1 Chr. 11:30; 1 Chr. 27:13

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The other man is listed by his father's name. His own name is spelled two ways:

Baanah. Father of Heleb, or Heled, one of David's mighty men. 2 Sam. 23:29; 1 Chr. 11:30.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

What the cave made of them

The title "mighty men" was not what these men brought with them. It was what they became through being near David.

All these found a sure refuge with David, just as people find refuge today with a rejected Christ. But they found much more. David is able to create, to form, the most wretched beings in his own image. The reflection of his moral beauty falls on those who have nothing to bring him but their misery. In the dark cave of Adullam, the light shining from David shines on these four hundred men around him. What grace made of them in the day of trouble will be seen by all eyes and praised by every mouth in the day of glory that is already near.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Nothing dropped from the list

Names like Maharai's would be lost if God had not kept them. That is what this list promises every unnoticed servant.

Because they were linked with David, his men had to go through much toil and weariness. But love made it all light and easy to them. And their names and deeds were recorded and faithfully remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten… Men may not see, know, or even think of these acts. But Jesus knows them, and He will declare them openly from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known what David's heroes did if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Ranks, but no rivalry

The list has ranks. Maharai and Heled are not among the top three, yet each man still gets his own reward.

Israel had many thousands of people — circumcised members of the congregation, children of Abraham. Yet only a few stood out for personal devotion and wholehearted consecration. Even among those few there were marked differences. There were "the thirty," "the three," and "the first three." Each gets his own place… Nothing is forgotten. All of it is faithfully recorded, and no one can ever take another's place. Each does his own work, fills his own niche, and gets his own reward.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

A day of public reward

The list includes men whose deeds are never told. One writer looks ahead to the day when all of it comes to light.

They were the men who loved David, stood by him, showed their loyalty and devotion to the King. And others are given, of whom we read no definite deeds… Before the judgment seat of Christ everything will be made clear. He will come as the righteous Ruler and bring in the cloudless morning. Then He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him while He was rejected. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Summary

- Choose — these men picked the hunted David over Saul on his throne. The list records loyalty in a day of rejection.

- Change — none of them brought greatness with them. Being near David shaped the wretched into his own likeness.

- Recorded — we read of no deed by Maharai or Heled. Yet the Holy Spirit kept their names, their father, and their village. None were forgotten.

- Placed — the thirty, the three, the first three: each keeps his own niche and his own reward, and no one can take another's.

- Declared — what is hidden now comes to light later. When the King rules in the open, no name and no deed, even the smallest, will be missing.

1 Chronicles 11:31 · Darby

Ittai the son of Ribai of Gibeah of the children of Benjamin, Benaiah the Pirathonite,

This verse is one line from the long roll of David's warriors: two men named, two hometowns given, no battle and no exploit told. So why does Scripture keep such names, and what does it mean that one man came from Saul's own town?

A list from David's hunted years

The whole list belongs to a time when siding with David cost something:

A wonderful illustration of devotedness is given in the list of David's mighty men in 1 Chronicles 11. The choice lay between Saul and David — Saul a picture of the natural, fleshly man, and David a picture of Christ. Saul is in the palace. He sits on the throne. The kingdom is at his feet. David is in the cave of Adullam with a band of men gathered round him, drawn by love for him and devoted to his cause.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Gibeah — Saul's own town

The first man's hometown carries weight:

City of Benjamin, the native place of Saul. Judges 19:12-16; Judges 20:4-43; 1 Sam. 10:26... The same city is called 'GIBEAH OF BENJAMIN,' 1 Sam. 13:2, 15, 16... and 'GIBEAH OF SAUL,' 1 Sam. 11:4; 1 Sam. 15:34; 2 Sam. 21:6; Isa. 10:29.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Men of that tribe who crossed over to David had to break with their own families. Saul took it hard:

It was a great grief to Saul, the king of Israel, that his son Jonathan was an admirer and friend of David, his enemy. Just as painful to him was the desertion of three thousand men of his own tribe of Benjamin to David. They overcame the ties and duties of family, and threw in their lot with the persecuted David. They could have chosen to stay with Saul. He was the Lord's anointed, and safety and strength seemed to be on his side.

Modernised from Truth & TestimonyOriginal wording

The same man, two spellings

In the parallel list in 2 Samuel the name is spelled differently. It is the same soldier:

Son of Ribai a Benjamite, and one of David's mighty men. 2 Sam. 23:29. Called ITHAI in 1 Chr. 11:31.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

A name with no deed

Other men in this chapter have deeds attached to their names. These two have none, and one writer notes that they are not alone:

Many other names are also listed among David's worthies, with no special mark of devotedness and no victories recorded.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Where a deed was done, God kept it on record. One writer sees a settled habit of God in that:

There are others, however. They are not among the three mightiest, but they were most honourable. God loves to mention what is an honour to His people, and so, after each of their names, we find a record of their deeds. The Lord will do this and more for those who now and ever have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Each man in his own rank

The list has ranks, and each man keeps his own place in it:

Each one has his own special place on the roll, and each one his place in the Master's heart; and all will come out by and by. Among David's mighty men we have "the first three," "the three" and "the thirty." Not one of "the thirty" ever reached a place among "the three." And not one of "the three" ever reached "the first three."

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

From the hard years into the kingdom

Benaiah of Pirathon does not vanish after this list. His name appears again later in Chronicles:

One of David's valiant men, a Pirathonite. 2 Sam. 23:30; 1 Chr. 11:31; 1 Chr. 27:14.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

One writer draws the lesson of the whole list — hardship first, honour afterwards:

Because they were joined to David, his men had to face much toil and weariness, but love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and deeds were recorded and faithfully remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten... This leads our minds on to the time when the Lord Christ will reward His faithful servants — those who, out of love for Him and by the power of His Spirit, have done acts of service for Him while He was rejected. Men may never see, know, or think of these acts. But Jesus knows them, and He will declare them publicly from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known the acts of David's worthies if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Cost — the list was earned while David was still hunted. Standing with him meant leaving the man who held the palace and the throne.

- Kin — Ithai came from Saul's own town in Benjamin. Men of that tribe who joined David had to break with their own families.

- Name — the same soldier is called Ittai in the parallel list of 2 Samuel 23:29. One man, two spellings, one place on the list.

- Record — no exploit is told of either man here, yet both are named. God loves to mention whatever brings His people honour.

- Reward — Benaiah of Pirathon is named again later in Chronicles. None who shared the hard years were forgotten when David came to rest, and Christ will declare His servants' work from the throne of His glory.

1 Chronicles 11:32 · Darby

Hurai of the brooks of Gaash, Abiel the Arbathite,

These two names belong to the roll of David's mighty men, listed at the start of his reign. We know each man only by a name and a home district. So why does God keep such a list, and what did these men do to earn a place in it?

Why Scripture Keeps Lists of Names

Most readers skip lists of names like this one. One writer admits he did the same:

So we can see that these genealogies had a far higher character than might appear at first. I have no doubt that most of us have read them and thought it was high time to skip over them. I have no doubt we have often wondered why they were written at all, and why they should be in the Bible... But I am quite sure that very few people have a clear, definite judgment about why God has attached so much importance to these genealogies.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The Men Who Brought In The Kingdom

The same men appear in 2 Samuel 23, but at the end of David's story. The placement changes what the list is for:

David's mighty men are listed at the beginning of this account (vv. 10-47), while in 2 Samuel 23 they come at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom... So our chapter mentions 81 mighty men, 30 of them recorded without being named. 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. There they are counted as the supporters David needed to confirm his throne. In our chapter they only have to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The Two Men Named Here

Both men here carry a second name in the parallel list. The first is named after the place he came from:

A hill in the district of Mount Ephraim. Joshua was buried on its side. Joshua 24:30; Judges 2:9. Hiddai, or Hurai, came from "the brooks [valleys, margin] of Gaash." 2 Sam. 23:30; 1 Chr. 11:32.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The second name also comes in two forms:

One of David's mighty men, 1 Chr. 11:32; he is called Abi-Albon in 2 Sam. 23:31.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

What This List Leaves Out

The two lists differ in more than spelling. One name is handled very differently here:

Notice an even more remarkable detail. Uriah the Hittite closes the list in 2 Samuel 23 as a witness against David's sin and fall. Here he appears hidden among the other mighty men (v. 41). His name is not held up as the accuser of David and of what was the shame of his kingdom. In the same way, this account passes over in complete silence everything to do with the terrible fall of the Lord's anointed.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

A Record Of Their Deeds

The chapter does not just count these men. It records what each one did:

There are others, though — not among the three mightiest, it is true, but still most honourable. God loves to mention what is an honour to His people, and so after each of their names we find a record of their deeds. The Lord will do this and more for those who now and always have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The hard years cost these men real effort, and none of it was lost:

Because David's men were linked with him, they had to endure much toil and weariness, but love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and deeds were recorded and remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten... Men may not see, know, or even think of these acts; but Jesus knows them, and will declare them openly from the throne of His glory.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Small Service In The Time Of Rejection

What put men like Hurai and Abiel on this roll was not the scale of their work but when they gave it:

About 3,000 years ago David became God's king in Israel, and he had many devoted servants. Yet it seems clear that no service was worth more in his eyes than that of the brave men who threw in their lot with him while Saul hunted and persecuted him. Sometimes they served him in very small things, yet that was the service he rewarded so richly when the kingdom at last became his.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Another writer draws the line to our own day:

Our Lord is now rejected, but "The crowning day is coming by-and-by." Now is the time to show which side we are on... Devotedness is not waiting for tasks that will put us in the public eye, or for work that is spectacular. It is being ready to do the humblest, lowliest work that needs doing in the service of the Lord.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- Named — Hurai and Abiel appear in 2 Samuel as Hiddai and Abi-albon. God keeps both forms, and the home valley too.

- Chosen — in Chronicles the list stands at the start of the reign. These men do not prop up a shaky throne. They acknowledge the king God had already given.

- Covered — Samuel's list exposes David's shame. Here Uriah is hidden among the mighty men, and the fall is passed over in silence.

- Recorded — God loves to mention what honours His people. Each name carries its deeds, and none were forgotten when David came to rest.

- Rewarded — small service given while the king was still rejected won a place on the roll. Christ will declare that same service from the throne.

1 Chronicles 11:33 · Darby

Azmaveth the Baharumite, Eliahba the Shaalbonite,

Two names stand side by side in the roll of David's fighting men. Each man is marked only by the town or clan he came from. Neither gets a deed of his own here. So why do their names stay on the page at all?

Two Names Among the Thirty

Reference works add only a line to each name. Azmaveth first:

The designation of Azmaveth, one of David's thirty valiant men.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Eliahba, next in the verse:

The Shaalbonite, one of David's thirty mighty men.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Honoured Without a Story

These two men are not the only ones listed without a story:

Many other names are also ranked among David's worthies with no special mark of devotedness and no record of victories.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

The Side They Had Taken

A place on this list started with a choice between two men:

The list of David's mighty men in 1 Chronicles 11 gives a wonderful illustration of devotedness. The choice lay between Saul and David — Saul an illustration of the carnal man and David a type of Christ. Saul is in the palace. He sits on the throne. The kingdom is at his feet. David is in the cave of Adullam with a band of men gathered round him, drawn by affection and devoted to his cause.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

What Actually Put Them on the List

For men like these two, whose deeds go unmentioned, another writer locates the qualifying thing somewhere other than achievement:

It was not simply that they purged themselves from Saul and his supporters. They did that. But what put them among the mighty men was their actual coming "to David." They were not to be thinking about what they had left behind. They were with David, ready for the battles that cleared the way to the throne. Their work had a positive character about it, and so success was sure, even though it took energy and conflict. Can we truly say we are separated to Christ? Are we with those who are with Him?

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Ranks Inside the List

The list is not flat. It sorts these men into ranks:

Out of the many thousands of Israel — circumcised members of the congregation, children of Abraham — only a few stood out for personal devotedness and wholehearted consecration. Even among those few there were marked differences. There were "the thirty," "the three," and "the first three." Each gets his own place in the book of responsible, practical life. That place matches what he was or what he had done. We are even told exactly what each man did and how he did it. Nothing is forgotten. It is all recorded faithfully, and no one can ever take another's place. Each does his own work, fills his own niche, and gets his own reward.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The same writer carries this forward from David's kingdom to Christ's:

Because they were linked with David, his men had to face much toil and hardship. But love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and deeds were written down and remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. Not one was forgotten. Second Samuel 23 gives the reader that precious list, and it leads the mind on to the time when the Lord Christ will reward His faithful servants — those who, out of love for Him and by the energy of His Spirit, have served Him in the time of His rejection. Men may never see, know, or even think of these acts. But Jesus knows them, and He will declare them openly from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known the acts of David's worthies if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The Names That Are Not Here

Obscure men appear on this list. Some famous men do not. One writer takes that silence as part of the message:

Whatever we make of Jonathan, who loved David so much, other names are missing from the list of mighty men altogether. And Scripture is not entirely silent about the reason why. Notice that the greatest warrior, the wisest counsellor, and one of the chief religious officials are all missing from the list of the king's worthies. We mean Joab, Ahithophel, and Abiathar.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Summary

- Came. We know these two only by where they came from. What put men among the mighty was their actual coming to David, not what they left behind.

- Counted. Both stand among David's thirty. In Israel the choice lay between Saul on the throne and David in the cave.

- Recorded. No deed of theirs is told, yet their names stay on the page. Hidden service is never lost; Jesus will declare it from the throne of His glory.

- Ranked. The thirty, the three, and the first three stay distinct. No one can take another's place, and each gets his own reward.

- Missing. Joab, Ahithophel and Abiathar — the strongest, the wisest, the most religious — are not on this list. Being unknown keeps no one off the list. Being famous puts no one on it.

1 Chronicles 11:34 · Darby

Bene-Hashem the Gizonite, Jonathan the son of Shage the Hararite,

Two names stand here with no story attached. We get a man, his father, and his home district — nothing more — yet both are set in the roll of the warriors who brought David to the throne. Why does God keep names in Scripture when He records nothing else about them?

Who These Men Were

A Bible dictionary gathers the little we know about the first name, and links it to the matching list in 2 Samuel 23:

Hashem. A Gizonite, the father of some of David's mighty men. 1 Chronicles 11:34. He seems to be the same man as Jashen in 2 Samuel 23:32.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Even less is known about the second word in his name:

Gizonite. The title given to Hashem, whose sons were among David's guard. Where the name comes from is not known. 1 Chronicles 11:34.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The Side They Chose

These names belong to a moment of choice. Two men had a claim on Israel, and these men went to the one with no throne.

The list of David's mighty men in 1 Chronicles 11 is a wonderful picture of devotion. The choice lay between Saul and David — Saul a picture of the man who lives for himself, and David a picture of Christ. Saul is in the palace. He sits on the throne. The kingdom is at his feet. David is in the cave of Adullam. A band of men have gathered round him. Love has drawn them, and they are devoted to his cause.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

A Name With No Exploit Attached

Some men in this list have a deed attached to their name. Hashem and Jonathan do not. One writer says plainly what is missing:

Many other names are also counted among David's mighty men, with no special mark of devotion and no victories recorded.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

The reason any of these men are known at all is that God chose to write them down.

Because they belonged to David, his men had to go through much toil and weariness. But love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and their deeds were written down and remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. No one was forgotten… Who would ever have known what David's mighty men did if the Holy Spirit had not recorded it? Who would have known about the three who drew water from the well of Bethlehem? Who would have known about the lion killed in a pit on a day of snow?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Which Jonathan?

The second man in this verse is Jonathan, son of Shagee. Is he the Jonathan who was Saul's son and David's closest friend? One writer leaves the question open, and draws a lesson from the silence around the name:

It is true that the name Jonathan does appear in verse 32. But we cannot tell whether this is the Jonathan who loved David as his own soul. And if it is, there is no particular record of his devotion. The reason is plain. Jonathan was earnest and whole-hearted in his attachment to David up to a certain point. But he never broke with his family and the royal court to bear David's reproach, and he never took the place of rejection outside the camp… His deep love for David is beyond question. Yet holding on to the house of Saul by family ties teaches us a solemn lesson: it seems to have cost him his life, and it kept him from full service to the man after God's own heart.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Why This List Sits Where It Does

The same roll appears twice in the Bible, and the two versions are not identical. One commentator counts the entries and explains the placement:

This account lists David's mighty men at the beginning (vv. 10-47), while 2 Samuel 23 lists them at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom… So our chapter refers to 81 mighty men, 30 of them recorded without being named. 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. There they are listed as supporters whom David needed to make his throne secure. In our chapter they have only to acknowledge what God had done in setting David up as His anointed.

Modernised from Henri L. RossierOriginal wording

Another writer admits how little can be drawn from bare names, and turns that into a call to study rather than to skip:

Of the thirty (thirty-one), known only by their names, little can be said also till they have been more minutely studied… It is just in such lists as this also, dry and barren as they have been suffered to remain through our negligence, that we may expect to find textual errors abounding… Let the people of God study His word; dig deep, and expect much.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

The Day the List Is Read Out

A day is coming when the true account will be public. That changes how service is weighed now.

Right now we know very little about how far people are true to the Lord. But the time will come when everyone will be shown for what they are… Those who are thought much of now may be missing altogether from the list of the faithful. And many whose service is valued at little now may then shine out to the abundant praise and honour of the Lord Jesus.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Summary

- Listed. No one knows where Hashem came from, and his sons go unnamed. God still put his name in the roll of David's guard.

- Listed because of David. What put these men on the list was joining a rejected king while the palace still belonged to Saul.

- Listed without a story. Many here have no victory or act of devotion recorded — the name alone is their record.

- Listed by God, not by fame. No one would know any of these deeds if the Holy Spirit had not written them down. The honour comes from His record, not from public notice.

- Listed for the day of glory. Some names valued now will be missing then, and quiet service will shine out to the praise of the Lord Jesus.

1 Chronicles 11:35 · Darby

Ahiam the son of Sacar the Hararite, Eliphal the son of Ur,

This line in the roll of David's warriors carries no story. It names two men only by their fathers. So why does Scripture keep names whose deeds it never tells us?

The men behind the names

One dictionary entry gathers all Scripture says about Ahiam's father, including a second form of his name:

A Hararite, father of Ahiam, one of David's mighty men. 1 Chr. 11:35. Called SHARAR in 2 Sam. 23:33.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The entry for the other father in the verse is shorter still:

Father of Eliphal one of David's mighty men. 1 Chr. 11:35.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Why this list stands where it does

The same roll appears in 2 Samuel 23, but at the end of that account rather than at the start. One writer shows what that placing does to the whole list:

This account lists David's mighty men at the beginning (vv. 10-47), while 2 Samuel 23 lists them at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom. They "gave him strong support in his kingdom, together with all Israel, to make him king, according to the word of the LORD concerning Israel" (v. 10), so carrying out the plans God had made known beforehand. A few names mentioned in Samuel are left out here, and a great many are added. Our chapter refers to 81 mighty men (30 of them recorded without being named); 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. There they are listed as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our present chapter they have only to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The differences in spelling and detail

The two lists do not match at every point. Ahiam's father is Sachar here and Sharar in 2 Samuel. One writer faces such differences head on, and turns them into a call to dig:

Of the thirty (thirty-one), known only by their names, little can be said until they have been studied more closely. Chronicles, as everyone knows, gives much the same list (1 Chron. 11), with additions at the end. Yet it differs a great deal when we come to details. It is just in lists like this — dry and barren, since we have let them stay that way through our own neglect — that we may expect to find many textual errors… Let the people of God study His word; dig deep, and expect much.

Modernised from F. W. GrantOriginal wording

God's pleasure in naming His own

One writer turns to the men below the top three, and to why God names them at all:

There are others, however — not among the three mightiest, it is true, but men who were most honourable. God loves to mention what is an honour to His people, and so after each of their names we find a record of their deeds. The Lord will do this and more for all who now and ever have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Each man in his own place

Few in Israel made this roll at all, and the roll itself has ranks inside it:

Out of the many thousands of Israel — circumcised members of the congregation, children of Abraham — only a few stood out by personal devotedness and wholehearted consecration. Even among those few there were marked differences. There were "the thirty," "the three," and "the first three." Each man gets his own place on the page of the book of responsible, practical life, according to what he was or what he had done… Nothing is forgotten. All of it stands faithfully recorded, and no one can ever get another's place. Each does his own work, fills his own niche, and gets his own reward.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

What a bare name asks of us

Our Lord's crowning day is still ahead, which puts a question to us now:

And shall there be no voice in this for us today? Our Lord is now rejected, but "The crowning day is coming by-and-by." Now is the time to show which side we are on. Now is the time to prize the cross as great reward. Devotedness is not waiting for tasks that will bring us into publicity, into work that is spectacular. It is a readiness to do the humblest, lowliest work that needs doing in the service of the Lord.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- Named. Ahiam's father appears as Sachar here and as Sharar in 2 Samuel. Eliphal's father is Ur, named only in this verse.

- Recorded. God loves to mention what is an honour to His people, so their names stand in His book though their deeds go untold here.

- Placed. In Chronicles the warriors come at the start. They bring in the kingdom and acknowledge what God had already done in establishing His anointed.

- Graded. There were the thirty, the three, and the first three; each gets his own place, and no one can ever take another's.

- Rewarded. The crowning day is coming, and devotedness now means readiness for the humblest work, not the spectacular.

1 Chronicles 11:36 · Darby

Hepher the Mecherathite, Ahijah the Pelonite,

This line carries nothing but two names and two labels, tucked inside a roll of eighty-one men who stood with David. So why does Scripture keep the names of Hepher and Ahijah, and tell us nothing about what they did?

The Roll of a King Already Crowned

In 2 Samuel these names come at the close of David's life. Here they come at the start of his reign. One writer draws out the difference in purpose.

David's mighty men are listed at the beginning of this account (vv. 10-47), while they are listed at the end in 2 Samuel 23. Here they bring in the kingdom. They "showed themselves valiant with him in his kingdom, with all Israel, to make him king, according to the word of Jehovah concerning Israel" (v. 10)... A few names mentioned in Samuel are left out here and a great many are added. So our chapter refers to 81 mighty men (30 of them recorded without being named); 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. In 2 Samuel they are listed as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our present chapter they have only to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

So Hepher and Ahijah stand here not as men David needed to secure his throne, but as men acknowledging a kingship God had already settled. Thirty men in the same list are never named at all; these two are.

Where Such Men Came From

David gathered these men while he himself was rejected. One writer points to where they came from.

The Lord of hosts is marshalling the strength and power of Israel. And the Holy Spirit gives a list of tried men of might. They are presented in the halo of their own prowess. The foremost of these worthies joined David while he was a fugitive and an outcast (1 Chron. 12:1-22); their origin is given (1 Sam. 22:2) and is an instance among many of God's taking up the despised of men and exalting them.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Words We Can No Longer Explain

Nobody can now say what either label means. A reference work gives the second one, and names the other man who shares it:

Designation of Helez and Ahijah, two of David's mighty men. Why they are so called is not known. 1 Chr. 11:27, 36; 1 Chr. 27:10. In 2 Sam. 23:26 Helez is called 'the Paltite.'

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The same work gives the first label, with only a guess at a link to the parallel list in Samuel:

Designation of Hepher. 1 Chr. 11:36. Perhaps the same as Maachathite in 2 Sam. 23:34.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Nothing Forgotten

We cannot identify these men. Someone else could, and that is what gives the list its value.

David's men were called to undergo much toil and fatigue, because of their association with him. But love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and exploits were recorded and faithfully remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten... These acts may not be seen, known, or thought of by men; but Jesus knows them, and will publicly declare them from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known the acts of David's worthies if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

What It Asks of Us

Our Lord is rejected now, as David once was. One writer asks what that should mean for us.

And shall there be no voice in this for us today? Our Lord is now rejected, but "The crowning day is coming by-and-by." Now is the time to show which side we are on. Now is the time to prize the cross as great reward. Devotedness is not seen in waiting for tasks that will bring us into publicity, into work that is spectacular. It is a readiness to do the humblest, most menial work that needs to be done in the service of the Lord.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- Gathered. These men joined David while he was a fugitive and an outcast — an instance of God taking up the despised of men and exalting them.

- Listed. In Chronicles the names stand at the start of the reign, and their work is to acknowledge what God had already done in making David king.

- Unknown. Why Ahijah is called a Pelonite is not known. Hepher's label may match a name in Samuel's list, but no one can say for sure.

- Remembered. Their names and deeds were recorded and remembered when David came to rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten.

- Rewarded. What men never see, Jesus will declare from the throne of His glory. So devotedness now means readiness for the humblest work, not the spectacular one.

1 Chronicles 11:37 · Darby

Hezro the Carmelite, Naarai the son of Ezbai,

One line in the register of David's warriors gives two men and nothing else — no battle, no speech, only a home town and a father's name. So why does God's word keep names like these, and what does it promise to anyone whose service nobody writes down?

Who These Two Were

The verse names Hezro by his town, Carmel, and tells us nothing else about him. Of Naarai, what is known is so thin that even his identity stays uncertain:

Son of Ezbai and one of David's mighty men. 1 Chr. 11:37. Perhaps, as in the margin, the same as PAARAI the Arbite in 2 Sam. 23:35.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Of his father, even less survives — one line in one verse:

Father of Naarai, one of David's mighty men. 1 Chr. 11:37.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Why the List Exists

These names belong to men who attached themselves to David while Saul still held the throne. To weigh what this band of men was worth, one writer sends the reader from David's days in the cave of Adullam to this very chapter:

There his own family came to him for protection, since they were no longer safe in Bethlehem. Others came too, four hundred of them, men of no standing — "in distress," "in debt" and "bitter in soul" (1 Sam. 22). His position has changed… We must turn to 1 Chron. 11:10-47 to understand the true worth of this little band gathered to David in the cave.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

What put a man among these men was not just leaving Saul. It was joining the rejected king:

They did not only cut themselves off from Saul and his supporters. They did that; but what put them among the mighty men was their actually coming "to David." They were not to dwell on what they had left behind. They were with David, ready for the battles that opened the way to the throne. Their work had a positive character, and so success was secured, even though it took energy and conflict.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Named Without a Story

Commentators read the silence around names like these in different ways. One points to the deeds written beside the honoured names, and to why God records them:

There are others, however. They were not among the three mightiest, but they were most honourable. God loves to mention what is an honour to His people, and so after each of their names we find a record of their deeds. The Lord will do this and more for all who have ever lived and suffered for His name.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Another points out that many names in the list carry no deed at all:

Many other names are also counted among David's worthies, with no special mark of devotion and no victories recorded.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Where the Two Lists Diverge

One writer admits plainly how little we know of these names, and how far the two lists differ:

Of the thirty (thirty-one), known only by their names, we can say little until they have been studied more closely. Chronicles gives much the same list (1 Chron. 11), with additions at the end, yet it differs a great deal in the details… Let the people of God study His word; dig deep, and expect much.

Modernised from F W GrantOriginal wording

Close to the King, and No Rival

Being one of the thirty meant nearness, and nearness meant a settled sense of who came first:

The thirty mighty men who were with David held a place close to him. No doubt they learned lessons from him that won them the honours they came to hold. They owed everything to David. They would rightly value Joab and the other captains, but David held the first place in all their hearts and minds. He was God's anointed one. There must be no rival.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The Day the Record Is Read Out

Hard service for David ended in a record that kept his men's names. One writer sees the same ahead for those who serve Christ while the world still refuses Him:

Because they belonged to David, his men faced much toil and weariness, but love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and deeds were written down and kept in memory when David was at rest in his kingdom. Not one was forgotten… Men may never see these acts, know them, or give them a thought; but Jesus knows them, and He will declare them openly from the throne of His glory.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Named. We know Hezro and Naarai only by name, home and father. One reference work suggests Naarai may be the Paarai of the parallel list.

- Chosen. What put a man on this roll was coming to David while he was still rejected — leaving Saul was not enough.

- Honoured. Some writers point to the deed recorded beside each honoured name. Others note that many names carry no deed at all.

- Near. The thirty owed everything to David. They valued the captains, but gave David the first place and allowed no rival.

- Remembered. Toil shared in the days of rejection became a record kept and read out in the day of the kingdom — none forgotten.

1 Chronicles 11:38 · Darby

Joel the brother of Nathan, Mibhar the son of Hagri,

One line in a long roll: a man known as somebody's brother, and a man known as somebody's son. Neither has one recorded deed. So why does God keep their names at all? And what does their place in the list say about the King they served?

Position of the list

Chronicles tells David's story differently from 2 Samuel. The same men appear in both books, but not at the same point in the story.

David's mighty men are listed at the beginning of this account (vv. 10-47), while in 2 Samuel 23 they are listed at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom. They "showed themselves valiant with him in his kingdom, with all Israel, to make him king, according to the word of the LORD concerning Israel" (v. 10, in the writer's older translation). So they carried out the plans God had made known beforehand. Then they are listed. Among the first three, Shammah is mentioned but not named. A few names from Samuel are left out here, and many more are added. So our chapter lists 81 mighty men, and 30 of them are recorded without being named. 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. There they stand as supporters whom David needed to secure his throne. In our chapter they only have to acknowledge what God had done in making David His anointed.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Source of their strength

Joel and Mibhar are counted among mighty men. But this chapter does not credit their courage to the men themselves. It points to the king they stood with.

God at once surrounds David with mighty men of valour. And the tribes of Israel send their thousands, "men of war that could keep rank" — well disciplined, as we would say. Who had disciplined these men? Just before, they had abandoned their cities and hidden in fear of the Philistines. God's chosen man was there, anointed to be king over Israel, and the kingdom was turned to him. This is the reason for their sudden gift of valour and might.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Names carried without deeds

By verse 38 the famous deeds are long past. These are names without stories. Writing on the matching list in 2 Samuel, Rossier turns to the least renowned group.

Finally we find the "thirty," less renowned than the six preceding men, although the Lord forgets none of His own.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The list has ranks, and the ranks hold. No one climbs.

Each one has his own special place on the roll, and each one his place in the Master's heart. It will all come to light later on. Amongst David's mighty men, we have "the first three" — "the three" and "the thirty." Not one of "the thirty" ever attained a place among "the three;" nor did one of "the three" ever reach to "the first three."

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Record kept for the day of reward

A name written down is a name that will be read out. Mackintosh looks past David to a greater King and a later day.

Because they belonged with David, his men had to go through much toil and weariness. But love made it all light and easy for them. And their names and deeds were written down and remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten… Men may never see these acts, know them, or think of them. But Jesus knows them, and He will declare them openly from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known the acts of David's worthies if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Devotion measured differently

If most of these men are remembered without a famous deed, then the size of the deed is not the measure. Pollock applies this to service today.

Devotion is not waiting for tasks that put us in the public eye, for work that looks spectacular. It is a readiness to do the humblest, lowliest work that needs doing in the service of the Lord… On the coming day when everything is shown, reading the Scriptures to a blind person may be valued more highly than the work of a popular preacher who can draw the crowds.

Modernised from A. J. PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- King first. In Chronicles the list opens David's reign instead of closing it. These men do not prop up a throne; they acknowledge one God had already given.

- Strength borrowed. Men who had been hiding in fear become mighty because God's anointed king is among them. The valour comes from him, not from them.

- Roll graded. There is a first three, a three, and a thirty. No one moves between them. Each has his own place on the roll and in the Master's heart.

- None dropped. Joel and Mibhar have no recorded deed, yet God writes their names down, because the Lord forgets none of His own.

- Day coming. What men never saw, Christ will announce from the throne of glory. So the humblest unseen service can outweigh the spectacular kind.

1 Chronicles 11:39 · Darby

Zelek the Ammonite, Naharai the Berothite, the armour-bearer of Joab the son of Zeruiah,

Two men appear here with no deed recorded for either: a foreigner from Ammon, and a man known as Joab's armour-bearer. So why does the list name them at all?

The list's place in Chronicles

This list of warriors also appears in 2 Samuel 23, but at a different point in the story.

Chronicles lists David's mighty men at the beginning of this account (vv. 10-47), while 2 Samuel 23 lists them at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom... In 2 Samuel 23 they appear as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our chapter they have only to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

A stranger written in

The verse calls Zelek an Ammonite, a man from outside Israel. He is not the only foreigner on the list.

Nor were "the sons of the stranger" overlooked at a time when the Lord so generously blessed Israel. For the Spirit of God, "when He registers the peoples," graciously includes in the list of David's mighty men Zelek the Ammonite (1 Chron. 11:39), Uriah the Hittite (verse 41), and Ithmah the Moabite (verse 46). In this connection we would also mention the name of Ittai the Gittite, whose faithfulness to David, when he was a fugitive (2 Sam. 15:19-23), rebuked an ungrateful nation, and brought him the reward of a place among the chief commanders of David's army (2 Sam. 18:2).

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Naharai comes from Beeroth, a town that was not Israelite to begin with.

One of the four cities of the Hivites which deceived Joshua into making a treaty of peace. It was given to Benjamin... The inhabitants of the city were called BEEROTHITES.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The armour-bearer and his captain

The verse names Naharai by the master he served: Joab. Yet 2 Samuel 23 leaves Joab's own name out of the list. One writer reads that silence as a verdict on a long career.

For many long years he had been at the head of David's armies, honoured among the people of God, victorious over their enemies. But all this activity was without value, either in the eyes of God or in David's. He had no place among David's mighty men, an honour his armour-bearer received (2 Sam. 23:37)... He thought that he had served his lord, the king, faithfully; in fact, he had always sought his own advancement.

Modernised from Alfred GuignardOriginal wording

Nothing forgotten

These men served with no crowd watching. Their deeds survive only because the Holy Spirit recorded them.

Because they belonged to David, his men had to go through much toil and weariness. But love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and deeds stood on record, faithfully remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten... These acts may not be seen, known, or thought of by men; but Jesus knows them, and will publicly declare them from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known the deeds of David's worthies if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The service that counts

Serving David cost these men toil and weariness. One writer turns that into a question for us.

And shall there be no voice in this for us today? Our Lord is now rejected, but "The crowning day is coming by and by." Now is the time to show which side we are on. Now is the time to prize the cross as great reward. Devotion is not seen in waiting for tasks that will put us in the public eye, in work that is spectacular. It is seen in a readiness to do the humblest, most menial work that needs doing in the service of the Lord.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- Named — Zelek and Naharai have no recorded deed, yet the list holds their names. The record itself is their honour.

- Named strangers — Zelek the Ammonite stands beside a Hittite and a Moabite. God's notice reaches past Israel's borders to "the sons of the stranger."

- Named servant — Joab appears here only as the man whose armour Naharai carried. In 2 Samuel's list the great captain is missing and his servant is there.

- Named forever — no one would know these deeds if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them. None were forgotten.

- Named now — these men joined the king while he was rejected. The list calls us to humble, unspectacular service before the crowning day.

1 Chronicles 11:40 · Darby

Ira the Ithrite, Gareb the Ithrite,

Two more names close out this stretch of the roll of David's warriors. Neither man has a story attached — no giant killed, no field held, only a name and a family. So why does Scripture keep such names, and what put these men on the list at all? Commentators take up both questions.

Who the Ithrites were

Both men are called Ithrites. A Bible dictionary ties that name to a family group and a tribe:

Designation of Ira and Gareb, two of David's mighty men, described as among "the families of Kirjath-jearim," which links them with Judah.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Why the roll stands here

The same list appears in 2 Samuel 23, but at the close of David's reign. One writer weighs what that change of place does, and counts the names in each:

This account lists David's mighty men at the beginning (vv. 10-47), while 2 Samuel 23 lists them at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom… So our chapter mentions 81 mighty men (30 of them recorded without being named); 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. There the list shows them as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our chapter they have only to acknowledge what God had done in making David His anointed, and they can do nothing but support a kingship that has come out of the counsels of God Himself.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Named, with nothing else said

Ira and Gareb sit among a group whose deeds are never described. One writer states it simply:

Many other names are also ranked among David's worthies, with no special mark of devotedness and no victories recorded.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Another writer looks at a long list of names elsewhere in Scripture. He finds God's own care in the detail:

He delights to record every little act of service, every little loving gift. He never forgets the smallest thing; and not only does He not forget it Himself, but He takes special pains that untold millions shall read the record… He will go into what may look to us like tedious detail — even what people might call needless repetition — rather than leave out one name of any of His servants, or one item of their work.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

What put a man on this list

One writer names the one thing these men shared. It was something given, not earned — and it explains a famous absence:

What characterized David's mighty men therefore was the association that grace had given them with the Lord's anointed. Joab never had such a relationship; this book has shown that clearly. He served David for his own advantage, and his actions never sprang from fellowship with David, his head. Scripture passes his name over in silence.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Another writer notes who else is missing from the roll:

We may notice that the greatest warrior, the wisest counsellor, and one of the chief religious officials are all absent from the list of the king's worthies. We refer to Joab, Ahithophel, and Abiathar.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

The pattern for today

One writer sets David's cave beside Saul's throne, and finds a choice in it:

A wonderful illustration of devotedness is given in the list of David's mighty men in 1 Chronicles 11. The choice lay between Saul and David—Saul a picture of the worldly man and David a type of Christ. Saul is in the palace. He sits on the throne. The kingdom is at his feet. David is in the cave of Adullam with a band of men around him. Affection has drawn them, and they are devoted to his cause.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Another writer looks ahead to what such men will feel:

When the time of conflict and stress was over, how their hearts would rejoice! They had been given the honour of sharing those days of struggle with David. And when the day of Christ's glory dawns in heavenly beauty, the joy will be great for those who have shared today in the conflicts for His Name's sake and for the good of all His own.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Summary

- Named — Ira and Gareb are Ithrites, from the families of Kirjath-jearim, which ties them to Judah.

- Placed — Chronicles puts the roll at the start of the reign. Here the men bring the kingdom in; in 2 Samuel they support a throne already held. This list runs to 81 men, against 37 there.

- Qualified — what marks a mighty man is the association grace gave him with God's anointed, not his record. Joab, for all his force, gets no mention.

- Recorded — God will go into what looks like tedious detail rather than leave out one servant's name or one item of his work.

- Rewarded — those who share the rejected King's struggle now will find their joy in the day His glory appears.

1 Chronicles 11:41 · Darby

Uriah the Hittite, Zabad the son of Ahlai,

Verse 41 puts Uriah the Hittite in the long list of David's warriors. This one name touches David's darkest failure, and Chronicles hides it in the middle instead of placing it last, as 2 Samuel does.

A Roll That Establishes The King

This list appears twice in Scripture — in two different places, and with different numbers of names.

David's mighty men are listed at the beginning of this account (vv. 10-47), while in 2 Samuel 23 they are listed at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom... Chronicles leaves out a few names that Samuel mentions, and adds a great many. So our chapter refers to 81 mighty men (30 of them recorded without being named); 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. Samuel lists them as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. Here they only have to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Uriah Placed Among The Rest

Chronicles does not leave Uriah out, but it does not spotlight him either.

Let us note an even more remarkable detail. Uriah the Hittite, who closes the list in 2 Samuel 23 as a testimony against David's sin and fall, appears here hidden among the other mighty men (v. 41). His name is not highlighted as the accuser of David and of what was the shame of his kingdom.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Why Chronicles Stays Silent

The silence in Chronicles reaches further than one name.

The account of David and Bathsheba fills two chapters in Samuel (2 Sam. 11 - 12). Chronicles passes it over, except for the first step down that steep slope: "But David remained at Jerusalem." Sovereign grace moves straight on to David taking the crown off the head of the king of Rabbah. That crown was gold, set with precious stones, and it was placed on David's head. This is not the restoration of the soul of a failing saint. It is God restoring David to his official position as the picture of the One who is yet to come.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

The Same Name In 2 Samuel

For David himself the name carried a personal weight.

The Lord forgets none of His own. When David looked over the list of His servants, with what sorrow his eyes must have paused at the name of Uriah the Hittite, the last name in that list. He was among the mighty men, and not the least of those hearts devoted to the king and his people. And David had had him put to death to satisfy his own lust! His name stayed there as a testimony against the one whom he had served. This single name of Uriah reminded David of his whole past of shame and discipline. But he condemned himself and honoured the grace that had restored him, so he would never have dreamed of erasing that name from the book where it was recorded.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

A Hittite Among David's Heroes

"Hittite" marks Uriah out as a foreigner, and he is not the only one in these verses.

Nor were "the sons of the stranger" overlooked at a time when the Lord so generously blessed Israel. For the Spirit of God, "when He registers the peoples," graciously includes Zelek the Ammonite (1 Chron. 11:39), Uriah the Hittite (verse 41), and Ithmah the Moabite (verse 46) in the list of David's mighty men.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Uriah's background makes his loyalty remarkable.

This brave man was not an Israelite by birth. He was a Hittite, by nature an enemy of Israel. Yet he had come to Israel, he was loyal to the king of Israel, and he valued the ark of the LORD above everything else in the land he had adopted.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

Names Without Recorded Deeds

Zabad son of Ahlai, named beside Uriah in this verse, has no recorded deed at all.

They were the men who loved David, stood by him, and showed their loyalty and devotion to the king. Other names appear too, and we read of no definite deeds for them... Before the judgment seat of Christ everything will become clear. When He comes as the righteous Ruler, to bring in the morning without clouds, He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him in His rejection. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Summary

- The names listed — In Chronicles the roll comes at the start of the reign. These men acknowledge what God had already done in making David king.

- The name kept — Uriah appears among the mighty men. David, restored by grace, never thought of striking that name out of the record.

- The name shielded — Chronicles hides Uriah in the middle of the list and passes over David's sin. Its subject is the king restored to his official place, as a picture of the One still to come.

- The name of a stranger — The roll of honour includes a Hittite, a Moabite and an Ammonite. Uriah, born an enemy of Israel, valued the ark of the LORD above everything else.

- The name remembered — Some, like Zabad son of Ahlai, have no deed recorded at all. Yet no name and no service given to the rejected King will be forgotten when He reigns.

1 Chronicles 11:42 · Darby

Adina the son of Shiza the Reubenite, a captain of the Reubenites, and thirty with him;

One line in a long roll of warriors is all we have of Adina and the men under him. Two questions press in: why does God keep a register of names most readers skip, and why does the list count thirty men without naming one of them?

Why the List Comes First

The same men appear twice in Scripture, in two different places in the story. One writer weighs what each placement says, and counts how many go unnamed.

This account lists David's mighty men at the start (vv. 10-47). 2 Samuel 23 lists them at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom. They "gave him strong support in his kingdom, together with all Israel, to make him king, according to the word of the LORD concerning Israel" (v. 10)… Our chapter refers to 81 mighty men, and it records 30 of them without naming them. 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. There the list presents them as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our present chapter they have only to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed. They can do nothing else but support a kingship that came out of the counsels of God Himself.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The Choice Behind Every Name

Every man on this list first had to choose between two kings.

The list of David's mighty men in 1 Chronicles 11 gives a wonderful illustration of devotedness. The choice lay between Saul and David—Saul an illustration of the natural man and David a picture of Christ. Saul is in the palace. He sits on the throne. The kingdom is at his feet. David is in the cave of Adullam. A band of men has gathered round him. Affection draws them, and they are devoted to his cause.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

A Chief Out of Reuben

Adina came from Reuben. Where that tribe chose to live gave one writer reason for sober reflection.

The inheritance of the two and a half tribes on the east side of Jordan gives us matter for sober reflection. Note that Reuben and his companion Gad choose their inheritance on the east side of Jordan. Reuben had been displaced from his rights as firstborn, and so he suggests a coming short of the full purposes of God in the calling of His people… Notice that it is the cattle of these two tribes that keeps them east of Jordan, on the wilderness side — right on the border of the world, we might say. How often do business and earthly interests keep the children of God from entering fully and in practice into their heavenly calling!

Modernised from Samuel RidoutOriginal wording

Yet here a man of Reuben stands as a chief, with thirty men following him to David.

Thirty Counted, None Named

The thirty behind Adina are the unnamed thirty in that count of 81. Their record reaches as far as our own names.

There is something deeply solemn for the soul in being allowed to go over such a record. Man forgot these names long ago. God has remembered every one of them, with every detail of their pathway through this world. Some day mankind will lose our names too. But God will never forget us or our ways.

Modernised from C KnappOriginal wording

Recorded Now, Declared Later

Standing with David cost his men. What became of that cost once his kingdom came?

Because they were joined to David, his men had to go through much toil and weariness. But love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and deeds were recorded and faithfully remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten. That record will no doubt lead the reader's mind on to the time when the Lord Christ will reward His faithful servants. They did acts of service for Him out of love to His person and by the energy of His Spirit, in the time of His rejection. Men may never see these acts, know them, or think of them. But Jesus knows them, and He will declare them openly from the throne of His glory.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- With him. The whole verse turns on one word: thirty men were with Adina, and Adina was with David. This list records whose side each man took.

- The choice. Saul held the palace and the throne; David held a cave. Affection drew these men to David, not advantage.

- The chief. Adina came from Reuben. Its herds held that tribe east of the Jordan, on the wilderness side. Yet he stands here among David's chiefs.

- The thirty. The list counts thirty men and names none of them. Man forgets such names; God remembers every one, with every detail of their path.

- The day. The list exists because David came into his kingdom and forgot no one. Christ will openly declare, from the throne of His glory, the service given to Him in the time of His rejection.

1 Chronicles 11:43 · Darby

Hanan the son of Maachah, and Joshaphat the Mithnite,

Two names close the middle of a long roll of David's fighting men. We learn nothing about either one — no battle, no feat, only a father's name and a home town. That silence raises a question about the whole chapter: why does God keep a register of men whose deeds He never describes?

Where This Roll Stands in Chronicles

The same men appear in 2 Samuel 23, but there the list closes the record of David's reign. Here it opens the reign, and the roll runs longer — which is where names like these two come in.

David's mighty men appear at the beginning of this account (vv. 10–47), while in 2 Samuel 23 they appear at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom. They showed themselves valiant with him to make him king, "according to the word of the LORD concerning Israel" (v. 10). In this way they carried out the plans God had made known beforehand. A few names mentioned in Samuel are left out here, and a great many are added. So our chapter refers to 81 mighty men (30 of them recorded without being named); 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. There they appear as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our present chapter they have only to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed...

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Where the Might Came From

These were not born heroes. Not long before, the same men had run from the Philistines and left their towns. Something changed, and it was not the men.

God at once surrounds David with mighty men of valour... Who had trained these men? Just before, they had left their cities and hidden themselves out of fear of the Philistines. God's chosen man was there, who was anointed to be king over Israel, and the kingdom was turned to him. This is the reason for their sudden gift of valour and might.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

A Name with No Recorded Deed

Earlier in the chapter, each name carries an exploit beside it. By this point the record has thinned to names alone. Commentators read that silence as a promise.

They were the men who loved David, stood by him, showed their loyalty and devotion to the King. Others are listed too, and we read of no definite deeds from them... At the judgment seat of Christ everything will come to light. He will come as the righteous Ruler, to bring in the morning without clouds. Then He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him in His rejection. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Why God Writes Names at All

Long lists of unfamiliar names are the part of the Bible readers skip. God's own habit runs the other way.

God loves to mention what is an honour to His people... The Lord will do this and more for those who now and ever have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Outsiders on the List

Hanan is named only by his father, and Joshaphat only by his home town. The register reaches further still, past Israel's own borders.

Nor were "the sons of the stranger" overlooked at a time when the Lord so generously blessed Israel. For the Spirit of God, when He writes up the people, graciously includes in the list of David's mighty men Zelek the Ammonite (1 Chron. 11:39), Uriah the Hittite (verse 41), and Ithmah the Moabite (verse 46).

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

The Timing of Loyalty

What these men share is not achievement but timing. They committed themselves to David before the crown was on his head.

What we find here is the faith of many, a precious fruit of grace. This faith submits to the Lord's anointed and acknowledges him at a time when the eye of flesh could not discern him in his lowly condition. It is the same today for believers. Our David has not yet received a visible kingdom, but those who acknowledge Him while He is still the rejected king have a special place in the divine annals and are "more honourable than their brothers."

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Devotion like this shows itself in a particular kind of work.

The mark of such devotion is not seen in waiting for tasks that will bring us into publicity, into work that is spectacular. It shows instead in a readiness to do the humblest, most menial work that needs to be done in the service of the Lord.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- The king first. These men were frightened villagers until God's anointed stood among them. Their strength came from the true king's presence, not from themselves.

- The name recorded. Chronicles puts this roll at the start of the reign, because these men bring the kingdom in. It also runs longer than Samuel's list.

- The name without a deed. Hanan and Joshaphat have no exploit attached, yet they stand in the register. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will be forgotten.

- The name from outside. An Ammonite, a Hittite and a Moabite share the honours roll. God writes up the sons of the stranger alongside Israel's own.

- The name rewarded. Those who own the rejected King before His kingdom is visible hold a special place in the divine annals. Even the plainest, least noticed service counts there.

1 Chronicles 11:44 · Darby

Uzzia the Ashtarothite, Shama and Jeiel the sons of Hotham the Aroerite,

This verse adds three more names to the long roll of David's warriors: a man from Ashtaroth, and two brothers, the sons of Hotham of Aroer. Scripture records no deed for any of them. So why did the Spirit of God write their names down at all?

The Roll Placed at the Start of the Reign

The same body of men appears in 2 Samuel 23, but there the list closes David's story. In Chronicles it opens his reign, and the list itself is longer.

In this account David's mighty men are listed at the beginning (vv. 10-47); in 2 Samuel 23 they come at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom. They "gave him strong support in his kingdom, together with all Israel, to make him king, according to the word of the LORD concerning Israel" (v. 10), and so carried out what God had already made known… A few names mentioned in Samuel are left out here, and many more are added. So our chapter refers to 81 mighty men, 30 of them recorded without being named. 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. There they are counted as the supporters David needed to secure his throne. Here they have only to acknowledge what God had done in making David His anointed.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

These men are not propping up a shaky throne; they are recognising a kingship that came out of God's own purpose.

Men from Far Outside Judah

The name Uzzia carries his home town with it, and that town lay outside Israel's heartland.

A city of Bashan in the kingdom of Og, east of the Jordan. The half-tribe of Manasseh received it, and later it was set apart for the Levites.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

David's pull reached across the river.

Strangers Included by Name

Within a few verses of Uzzia stand men whose titles mark them out as foreigners.

God did not overlook "the sons of the stranger" at a time when the Lord blessed Israel so richly. For the Spirit of God, "when He registers the peoples," graciously includes in the list of David's mighty men Zelek the Ammonite (1 Chron. 11:39), Uriah the Hittite (verse 41), and Ithmah the Moabite (verse 46).

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

A Name with No Story Attached

Earlier in the chapter, the record tells of great deeds. By verse 44 only names remain, and that silence is not neglect.

Others are named, and we read of no definite deeds from them… Before the judgment seat of Christ everything will be brought to light. He is coming as the righteous Ruler, to bring in the morning without clouds. Then He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him while He was rejected. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

What Puts a Name on God's Register

Being a capable soldier was not the qualification. The most famous commander of the army is nowhere in these verses, while an unknown man from Ashtaroth is.

Joab held the top position as head of the army until the end of David's reign, yet the list of mighty men leaves him out. He had perhaps performed more brilliant actions than all the others. He had much courage, and even a certain outward devotion to the king. But qualities like these do not in themselves give anyone a place in God's register. Otherwise the Word would list almost all the great heroes of humanity… Psalm 87 teaches us what God means by "mighty men." The glory of the heroes of the nations was past, and it did not reach beyond their short lives, even though they had filled the earth with the fame of their names. But "of Zion it shall be said, 'This one and that one were born in her'" (v. 5). That was the character of David's mighty men: by their origin they counted as belonging to the city of royal grace.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The Pattern for Today

Commentators draw a line from David's rejected days to our own.

David was the anointed of God, and the throne of Israel was his. But it was during the time of his rejection that hardship and war tested and proved the true worth of his mighty men. So it is today. Our Lord Jesus Christ, the Anointed of God, is rejected by the world. It does not yet acknowledge Him as Lord of all. And to us "it has been granted that for the sake of Christ you should not only believe in Him but also suffer for His sake" (Phil. 1:29).

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Summary

- Kingdom — In Chronicles the roll stands at the start of the reign. These men do not secure David's throne. They own a kingship God had already settled.

- Reach — The list stretches east of the Jordan, and it takes in an Ammonite, a Hittite and a Moabite. Distance and birth are no barrier.

- Register — Brilliant service is not the entry ticket. God's register leaves out Joab, the army's chief, and writes in unknown Uzzia.

- Remembrance — These names carry no deed, yet nothing is lost. No name and no deed, however small, will be forgotten.

- Rejection — The test was loyalty while the king was still refused. So this roll calls for the same devotion now, while the world still refuses Christ.

1 Chronicles 11:45 · Darby

Jediael the son of Shimri, and Joha his brother, the Tizite,

Two brothers appear near the end of a long roll of David's men. The list gives them no exploit — only their father, their kinship, and a title no one can now explain. So why does God bother to write down men that nobody else remembers?

A Roll from the Cave

These names belong to men who joined David while Saul still hunted him. One writer points to this list as the key to what that ragged company was worth:

Because of Saul he is still a fugitive, and we find him in the cave of Adullam. There his own family come to him for protection, since they are no longer safe in Bethlehem; and others come too, four hundred of them, men of no reputation — "in distress," "in debt" and "bitter in soul" (1 Sam. 22). We must turn to 1 Chron. 11:10-47, to understand the true worth of this little band gathered to David in the cave.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Each man had to choose between two masters:

The choice lay between Saul and David — Saul a picture of the man ruled by his own nature, and David a picture of Christ. Saul is in the palace. He sits on the throne. The kingdom is at his feet. David is in the cave of Adullam with a band of men around him, drawn to him by love and devoted to his cause.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Where the Strength Came From

One writer traces the sudden courage of David's men to a single fact:

Who had disciplined these men, who just before had abandoned their cities and hidden themselves for fear of the Philistines? God's chosen man was there, anointed to be king over Israel, and the kingdom was turned to him. That is why they were suddenly given courage and strength... these great acts are only the natural result of the presence of His power. He is giving samples, so to speak, of what the power and the glory will be when He Himself takes the kingdom. Then greater deeds will be done.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Names Without Deeds

Jediael and Joha have no deed of their own on record. That silence is not a mistake:

They were the men who loved David, stood by him, showed their loyalty and devotion to the King. Others are also named, and of them we read no definite deeds... Before the judgment seat of Christ everything will be brought to light. When He comes as the righteous Ruler, to bring in the cloudless morning, He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him while He was rejected. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

One reference work can say only this much about his title:

The title of Joha, one of David's mighty men. 1 Chr. 11:45. Its meaning is not known.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Why God Writes the Names Down

One writer finds God's own reason for keeping such a record:

There are others too — not among the three mightiest, it is true, but still most honourable. God loves to mention what is an honour to His people; so after each of their names we find a record of their deeds. The Lord will do this and more for those who now, or at any time, have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

One famous soldier is missing from the list, and the reason shows what God's register really honours:

Joab, who held the top position as head of the army until the end of David's reign, is left out of his mighty men. Perhaps he had performed more brilliant deeds than all the others. He had much courage and even a certain outward devotion to the king, but such qualities in themselves do not give anyone a place in God's register. Otherwise the Word would list almost all the great heroes of mankind... The glory of these national heroes was over, and it never reached beyond their short lives, though they had filled the earth with the fame of their names... Such was the character of David's mighty men: by their birth they were counted as belonging to Zion, the city of royal grace.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The Day the List Is Read Out

Standing with David cost his men something:

Because they belonged to David, his men had to go through much toil and weariness, but love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and deeds were written down and remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten... Men may never see, know, or even think of such acts; but Jesus knows them, and will declare them openly from the throne of His glory.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Cave — These men joined David while he was a fugitive and Saul still held the throne.

- Choice — Every man on it chose the rejected king over the one on the throne, drawn by love.

- Courage — Their sudden might came from the presence of God's anointed among them. It was a sample of the power of the coming kingdom.

- Credit — God loves to mention what is an honour to His people; outward bravery alone wins no place in His register.

- Crown — Jediael and Joha have names but no recorded deeds. Yet no name and no deed, however small, will be forgotten when the King declares them from His throne.

1 Chronicles 11:46 · Darby

Eliel of Mahavim, and Jeribai, and Joshaviah, the sons of Elnaam, and Jithmah the Moabite,

A long list of names closes 1 Chronicles 11, and the last man in it comes from Moab. Why does the Spirit of God record names no one remembers? And what is a Moabite doing among David's honoured men?

Where the Roll Stands in the Story

Chronicles puts this list at the start of David's reign. In 2 Samuel 23 the same list comes at the end. One commentator draws out what that difference means.

This account lists David's mighty men at the beginning (vv. 10-47), while 2 Samuel 23 lists them at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom... A few names mentioned in Samuel are left out here, and a great many are added. So our chapter refers to 81 mighty men, 30 of them recorded without being named; 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. There they appear as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our present chapter they only have to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed.

Modernised from Henri L. RossierOriginal wording

So Ithmah stands among the names added here — men who simply acknowledge a throne God had already settled.

A Roll Written in Grace

The same list also leaves things out. It shows the men, not their king's worst hour.

Uriah the Hittite closes the list in 2 Samuel 23 as a witness against David's sin and fall. Here he appears hidden among the other mighty men (v. 41). His name is not held up as the accuser of David and of what was the shame of his kingdom. In the same way, this chapter says nothing at all about the terrible fall of the Lord's anointed.

Modernised from Henri L. RossierOriginal wording

The Stranger Included

Ithmah is not the only outsider in these closing verses.

The "sons of the stranger" were not overlooked at a time when the Lord blessed Israel so richly. For the Spirit of God, "when He writes up the people," graciously includes in the list of David's mighty men Zelek the Ammonite (1 Chron. 11:39), Uriah the Hittite (verse 41), and Ithmah the Moabite (verse 46). We would also mention Ittai the Gittite. His faithfulness to David, while David was on the run (2 Sam. 15:19-23), rebuked an ungrateful nation, and his reward was a place as one of the chief commanders of David's army (2 Sam. 18:2).

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

The word "Moabite" carried a legal barrier. One well-known Moabite faced that barrier, and God accepted her anyway.

The law of Moses says that no Moabite "may enter the assembly of the LORD. Even to the tenth generation, none of them may enter the assembly of the LORD forever" (Deut. 23:3). Yet Ruth chose to be counted with Israel, and Jehovah accepted her. Truly, "What is impossible with man is possible with God."

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

Names Nobody Remembers, Kept Forever

Eliel, Jeribai, Joshaviah — we know nothing about them beyond a line. One writer, looking at another such list in Numbers 7, drew one lesson from three of them.

May we not say that this seventh chapter of Numbers is one of those sample pages from the book of eternity? On it the finger of God has engraved the names of His servants, and the record of their work... Turn to 2 Samuel 23 and Romans 16, and you will find two similar pages. In the first we have the names and the deeds of David's mighty men; in the second, the names and the deeds of Paul's friends at Rome... Each one has his own special place on the roll, and each one his place in the Master's heart.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Why They Were There

These men joined David before he had a throne. One writer sets out the choice they faced.

The choice lay between Saul and David—Saul an illustration of the fleshly man, and David a picture of Christ. Saul is in the palace. He sits on the throne. The kingdom is at his feet. David is in the cave of Adullam, with a band of men gathered round him, drawn by affection and devoted to his cause.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

The same writer brings this into the present.

Our Lord is now rejected, but "The crowning day is coming by and by." Now is the time to show which side we are on... Devotion is not waiting for tasks that put us in the public eye, or for work that looks spectacular. It is a readiness to do the humblest, lowliest work that needs doing in the service of the Lord.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- Cause — These men chose the rejected king. Affection drew them to David in the cave, not to Saul on the throne.

- Grace — Chronicles lists them at the start of the reign. It hides Uriah among the rest instead of using him as evidence against David.

- Reach — The list reaches past Israel's borders. It names an Ammonite, a Hittite, and Ithmah the Moabite — and the law shut Moab out to the tenth generation.

- Record — God engraves names that mean nothing to us on a sample page from the book of eternity. Each servant has his own place on the roll and in the Master's heart.

- Result — Our King is still rejected, and the crowning day is coming. The way onto His roll is readiness for the humblest work, not the spectacular.

1 Chronicles 11:47 · Darby

Eliel, and Obed, and Jaasiel the Mezobaite.

The chapter's roll of David's warriors ends with three bare names, not with a famous deed. The last man is marked only by his home town. Why does God close the list this way, and why is Chronicles' list longer than the matching list in 2 Samuel 23?

Where the List Stands in Chronicles

This roll appears twice in Scripture, in two different places. Where it stands changes what it means. One writer counts both lists and explains what the longer version in Chronicles is doing:

This account lists David's mighty men at the start (vv. 10-47), while 2 Samuel 23 lists them at the end. Here they bring in the kingdom... Our chapter leaves out a few names that Samuel mentions, and adds a great many. So it refers to 81 mighty men (30 of them recorded but not named); 2 Samuel 23 names 37. In Samuel they appear as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In our chapter they only have to acknowledge what God had done in establishing David as His anointed. They cannot do other than support a kingship that came out of the counsels of God Himself.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The men in the final verses, then, are not late additions to a struggling cause. They stand with a king God has already settled on the throne.

Names Without Recorded Deeds

Eliel, Obed and Jaasiel have no battle attached to them. That is true of a whole group in this chapter:

Many other names are also ranked among David's worthies, with no special mark of devotedness and no victories recorded.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Another writer blames our own neglect for how little we know here, and expects such lists to hold errors in the text:

We know the thirty (thirty-one) only by their names, and little can be said about them until we study them more closely. Chronicles, as is well known, gives almost the same list (1 Chron. 11), with additions at the end, yet differs a great deal when we come to details. It is just in such lists as this, dry and barren as we have allowed them to remain through our neglect, that we may expect to find many errors in the text. Let the people of God study His word. Dig deep, and expect much. Then we shall soon have few such complete gaps in our knowledge as we have to regret here.

after_note: none

F. W. Grant

Who Is Missing

The last names are worth measuring against the names that never appear at all:

Other names are completely absent from the list of mighty men, and Scripture is not quite silent about why. Notice who is missing from the list of the king's worthies: the greatest warrior, the wisest counsellor, and one of the chief religious officials. We refer to Joab, Ahithophel, and Abiathar.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Ability, wisdom and religious office secured no place on this list. Being joined to God's anointed king did.

Remembered When the Kingdom Came

These names survive because the men behind them stood with David when it cost them. One writer traces that cost through to the written record:

Because they belonged to David, his men were called to go through much toil and weariness. But love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and deeds were recorded and faithfully remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten... Men may never see, know, or even think about these acts. But Jesus knows them, and He will declare them openly from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known the acts of David's worthies if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

What This Asks of Us

These men are on the list with no deed to their name. One writer draws out what that means for us:

And is there no voice in this for us today? Our Lord is now rejected, but "The crowning day is coming by-and-by." Now is the time to show which side we are on. Now is the time to prize the cross as great reward. Devotedness does not wait for tasks that put us in the public eye, or for work that looks spectacular. It is a readiness to do the humblest, most menial work that needs doing in the service of the Lord.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- Attached — Every man here, down to the last three, is on the list because he joined himself to God's anointed king. In Chronicles these men bring in the kingdom; they do not prop up a shaky throne.

- Enlarged — Chronicles adds many names at the end that Samuel leaves out: 81 men in all, against Samuel's 37.

- Unrecorded — Many here, including the last three names, have no deed and no mark of devotedness. Being on the list is the whole honour.

- Absent — Joab the greatest warrior, Ahithophel the wisest counsellor, and Abiathar a chief religious official are all missing. Skill, wisdom and office secured nothing here.

- Remembered — The Holy Spirit wrote down what men never saw. Jesus will declare from the throne of His glory what we do for Him now, while the world rejects Him.